OliverCowdery.com -- The Premier Web-Site for Early Mormon History


Bookshelf  |  Spalding Library  |  Mormon Classics  |  Newspapers  |  History Vault

Barbara A. Simon
(c.1790-aft.1836)
The Ten Tribes...
(London: Seeley & Burnside, 1836)

  • Title Page
  • Contents
  • Preliminary Matter
  • Israelite Migration
  • Gods and Religion
  • History and Peoples
  • Appendix

  • transcriber's comments



  • History of Mexico (1807)   |   Humboldt's Researches... (1814)   |   Star in the West (1816)
    Ruins of Ancient City (1822)   |   View of Hebrews (1823)   |   Antiquities of Mexico (1831)

    This web-document is still under construction
     





    THE  TEN  TRIBES  OF  ISRAEL

    HISTORICALLY  IDENTIFIED

    WITH  THE

    A B O R I G I N E S

    OF

    THE  WESTERN  HEMISPHERE.


    By  Mrs.  Simon.



    Behold! I was left alone: -- these, where had they been! --
    ISAIAH XLIX. 21.

    He that scattereth Israel will gather him, and keep him, as a shepherd doth his flock. --
    JEREMIAH xxxi. 10.




    PUBLISHED BY R. B. SEELEY AND W. BURNSIDE;
    AND SOLD BY L. AND G. SEELEY,
    FLEET STREET, LONDON.

    MDCCCXXXVI.



     

    v



    CONTENTS.


    vii-viii   NOTICE OFHE ANTIQUITIES OF MEXICO."

    ix-xl   PRELIMINARY OBSERVATIONS

    1-26   PRELIMINARY NOTICES OF SPANISH HISTORIANS
           (Page 23, line 16, for 'that,' read 'and the.')


    27-49   MIGRATION

    50-64   NAMES AND ATTRIBUTES OF THE CREATOR

    65-85   QUETZALCOATL

    86-88   THEOCRATIC GOVERNMENT

    89-148  RELIGIOUS  OBSERVANCES

    126-129   CIRCUMCISION

    135-148   FESTIVALS

    149-157   MEXICAN CALENDAR

    158-162   HISTORICAL RECORDS




    vi                                                               CONTENTS.                                                              


    163-173   LANGUAGE

    174-179   CHARACTERISTICS

    180-192   TRADITIONS

    193-200   TOLTICS OR TULIANS

    201-224   PERUVIANS

    225-258   HAYTIANS
           (Page 225, line 11, for 'a royal,' read 'the royal.')


    259-273   MEXICAN EMPIRE

    263-269   ADMINISTRATION OF LAW

    271-272   ARTS AND SCIENCES

    273-274   LAW OF SLAVES

    274-286   MEXICANS

    286-313   MONTEZUMA

    315-370   APPENDIX




    [ vii ]



    _____


    To "THE ANTIQUITIES OF MEXICO," the following pages are indebted for the most valuable portion of the testimony by which they are enriched.

    This rare and costly compilation, which was a few years ago published by the Right Honorable Lord Viscount Kingsborough, has hitherto been little known beyond the libraries of Universities, and those of a few Noblemen.

    "THE ANTIQUITIES OF MEXICO" at the present time consist of seven folio volumes, which, with the exception of the sixth, contain fac-similes and drawings from such historical remains, as had escaped the destruction to which all the primitive records and other memorials of the tribes of the New Continent had been condemned by the policy of their invaders in the fifteenth century.

    Literary and antiquarian travellers having from time to time transmitted these precious relics to their respective governments, they have been preserved in the Royal Libraries of Paris, Berlin, Dresden -- the Imperial Library of Vienna -- the Vatican Library, in the Museum at Rome, in the Library of the Institute of Bologna, and in the Bodleian Library, Oxford.

    As a specimen of the genius of a primitive race, over whose origin has long brooded a mysterious obscurity; and as a successful attainment in antiquarian research, the publication




    viii


    of Viscount Kingsborough is highly interesting and curious: but rising as it does to the sublime character of an illustration and confirmation of Scripture testimony, disclosing the Hebrew origin, history, experience, and genius of that grand division of the Hebrew nation, which although cut off for a series of ages from their own, and the nations of the earth, have nevertheless occupied a prominent place in the prophetic pages; the importance of such a testimony (at such an ominous crisis in the history of Christendom,) -- so miraculously preserved, -- so long withheld, -- so unexpectedly reclaimed; -- (whether in its internal or relative character) like the Bow of peace and promise, speaks of a PLACE and state of REST beyond the impending cloud of retributive storm.




    [ ix ]



    PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.
    _____


    Territorial empire was immediately after that purification which the earth received from the Deluge, assigned to the three surviving representatives of the present inhabitants of the globe: and the boundary of each was soon after specifically determined and defined. The appointment was one of unerring wisdom and universal goodness; but alienation of heart and mind from the divine supremacy soon manifested itself in that self-will which suggests covetous desires, and enforces these by arbitrary violence.

    The LORD blessed all the sons of Noah on their coming forth from the ark to inherit the baptised earth: it was by coveting the possession of territories beyond their rightful empire, that the sons of Ham forfeited that blessing in which they were originally included, and by this demonstration of rebellion against the appointments of the Most High, and usurpation of the rights of others, they incurred that curse by which they have been distinguished. 'Covetousness,' by withdrawing the mind and heart from the will of God, and by constituting some substituted object supreme in our regard, 'is,' in essence and effect 'idolatry.' Hence the incalculable evils of this early infringement of His authority who "appointed to all nations the bounds of their habitations."




    x                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    Self-will and licentious desires prepared the ungodly Ham for that malediction, which a specific provocation at length called forth. It was prophetically addressed to him as the father of Canaan, whose lawless and impious acts would justify the curse of degradation then pronounced by the patriarch.

    An isolated act of provocation would have called for a personal rebuke; but in that prophetic curse, Canaan, the son of the immediate delinquent, is specially implicated, and that most justly.

    That the malediction should have been given in the spirit of prophecy -- in a fore-knowledge of the character which would justify it, was in Israel a common occurrence. Children of eight days old were in this spirit so characteristically named, that not alone their own circumstances, but the history of their tribe was frequently involved in the prophetic appellation then given. The descriptive blessings of Jacob and of Moses to the heads of the twelve tribes, fully illustrate this truth.

    But why did Noah select Canaan as the worst branch of the family of Ham? did he not foresee that Cush also, and his sons, would invade a great portion of that territory allotted to one of the branches of the family of Shem? and that having thus rebelled against the divine appointment, they, on the warrant of the same self-will, would, in renouncing the authority of the Creator, constitute the "host of Heaven" the objects of their supreme regard and homage, together with those 'graven images' which should represent their famous leaders.

    Assuredly Noah had a premonition of their departure from the Most High, since he foresaw that Canaan would be guilty of a still more aggravated enormity.

    By sovereign right and choice, the Creator of all had




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                               xi


    selected a peculiar territorial domain as the seat of His government and administration.

    From its geographical position, JERUSALEM, the metropolitan city of this empire, is to the earth at large what the heart is to the human body -- the central seat of that life and energy which is diffused from thence to the most remote parts of the frame which it animates.

    The heinousness of Canaan's guilt was in having usurped this consecrated portion, knowing that it was claimed by the Creator as HIS inheritance, and delegated by HIM to the posterity of Shem, of whose line was to be born in due time, the Messiah. That this knowledge of the purpose of GOD was perfectly understood by Noah, and, doubtless, by him communicated to his sons, Ham and Japhet, there can be no doubt, since his manner of addressing Shem is demonstrative of that expectation. He does not say, Blessed art thou; or, blessed shalt thou be of the LORD; but, Blessed be the LORD GOD of Shem." [1]

    In sacreligiously usurping that LAND which in His wisdom the LORD had set apart for the occupancy of that peculiar People whom he had constituted the depository of His revealed mind and will -- which therefore they were appointed to minister to the nations of the earth, Canaan was not alone chargeable with disobedience, covetousness, and injustice, but thus became the means of introducing those detestable and demoralizing idol rites, which not alone would eventually cause the Land to cast them forth of it, but which would necessarily become snares to entrap, and lures to seduce from their allegiance, the rightful occupants who should sojourn amongst them.

    In the division of the earth it was inculcated upon Israel:

    __________
    1 Eusebius states, "that Noah explained to his sons the will of God, and allotted to each their particular territory, having received his instructions from Heaven." -- See Bryant's Myth.




    xii                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    "The LORD's portion is His people; Israel is the lot of His INHERITANCE;" accordingly it is testified -- "Unto thee will I give the land of Canaan, the lot of your inheritance." Because it was His, it became also theirs; the LORD's portion being His people. David elsewhere describes "Judah as His sanctuary." Israel as His dominion.

    The Hebrews therefore held the LORD's Land at will; and were subject to Him as Supreme Proprietor: - - "The Land shall not be sold for ever; for THE Land is MINE."

    It was this Holy portion which was invaded and appropriated by the race of Canaan; and not alone invaded and appropriated, but polluted by their detestable idol rites.

    Cush, or Cutha and his sons, under their lawless and self-intitled leader Nimrod, invaded the province of Shinar, in which rightfully dwelt Asshur, [1] a branch of Shem's family. "Nimrod," it is written, "was a mighty hunter" "before the LORD." A term which is scripturally indicative of the violence, crime, and disorder, of a reckless one. This self-willed ruler assumed the title of Alorus of Orion, [2] and subsequently as Belus, became an object of idolatrous worship after his decease.

    He was the first who assumed the establishment of an independent kingdom and government: -- "The beginning of his kingdom was BABEL." * * *

    His independent beginning, commenced in rebellion, and established in transgression, was carried on in opposition;

    __________
    1 It appears that the Assyrian Empire in its original grant to Ashur extended to the extreme eastern coast of Asia, which nearly unites, and probably was then, united to the westernmost coast of the New World.

    2 Bryant observes, "It is remarkable that the first tyrant upon earth masked his villainy under the meek title of Shepherd -- if we may credit Gentile writers, it was under this pretext that Nimrod framed his opposition, and gained an undue sovereignty over his brethren, having taken to himself the name of Orion, and giving out that he was born to be a protector and guardian; or, as it is related by Besorus, "He spread a report abroad that God had marked him out for a Shepherd of His people."




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                               xiii


    until that lawless combination of self-wills and self-interests which enmity to His will confederated for a time in one impious design, became by a just retribution so confounded by the confusion of their own speech and ideas, and consequently so estranged and divided in their efforts and purposes, that each party for itself spread abroad over the face of the country.

    "The Tower of Babel," observes Bryant, "was probably designed for an observatory for 'the Host of Heaven;' as well as for a land-mark and strong-hold against the power of the elements. The Ethnic writers describe whirlwinds as the cause of the overthrow of the Tower itself; from which Nimrod not being willing to depart, he was involved in its fall."

    The sons of Peleg, in whose days the division of the earth had taken place, were occupants of the territory assigned to their ancestor.

    From Ur of the Chaldees was Abraham called, as the federal head of that people, iu whom all the families of the earth should be blessed. At Haran, a border part of the Land, he sojourned for several years, but at the command of the LORD, pitched his tent with that of Lot, on a mountain in, or near Jerusalem, where "he built an altar to the LORD."

    The lawless occupants certainly knew that the Land should ultimately be possessed by the children of Abraham, for whom from the beginning it had been destined. This is to be inferred from that treaty which the king, attended by his chief captain Phicol, requested at the hand of Abraham in token of amity hereafter. "Now, therefore, swear unto me by God, that thou wilt not deal falsely with me, nor my son, nor my son's son," &c. The same thing happened to Isaac many years afterwards. The herdsmen of the king had assumed the right of compelling those of the patriarch to depart from the place




    xiv                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    where they were; which led the king, together wild his chief captain, to solicit personally a reconciliation. "And Isaac said unto them, Wherefore are ye come unto me, seeing ye hate me?" they said "We saw certainly that the LORD was with thee, and we said, let there be an oath betwixt us and thee; and let us make a covenant with thee that thou do us no hurt."

    Abraham having sojourned so long in the empire of the Chaldees, as to have given occasion to be considered a Chaldean by race, as well as by birth; we are pointedly informed that "SHEM was the father of all the children of Heber," the head of the Hebrew nation, whose name they inherit.

    Although as a Sovereign the LORD would not have acted arbitrarily in expelling the usurpers, he mercifully granted time and opportunity for their amendment, leaving the sins of an ungodly race to their own fatal reaction.

    To Abraham it was intimated that he should be gathered to his fathers in peace -- be buried in the Land, and that his children should be for a season in Egypt, from whence they should be delivered in the fourth generation, when "the iniquity of the Amorites" should be "full."

    When at length the LORD did conduct His people into the Land, He thus addressed them, "According to the doings of Egypt wherein ye dwelt; shall ye not do: and according to the doings of the Land of Canaan whither I bring you; ye shall not do. Ye shall observe MY statutes to keep MY ordinances, to walk therein: I AM the Lord your GOD."

    After an enumeration of the evils which were to be shunned, it is added, "For all these abominations have the men of the Land done, who were before you; and their Land is defiled, and the Land being defiled, therefore do I visit the iniquity thereof upon it; and the Land itself vomiteth out her inhabitants."




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                               xv


    Having contemplated the division of the earth into three shares, these having been appointed for the occupancy of the three sons of Noah throughout their generations, it may be asked, Had the Creator and disposer who is yet to be acknowledged as "the GOD of the whole earth," no ulterior design in reserving for some special purpose present to His foreknowledge, that vast transatlantic Hemisphere with which Christendom has but recently become acquainted?

    Although not included in his design of appropriation, when the division to which allusion has been made took place, surely it was as a consequence reserved for some extraordinary emergency illustrative of the character and government of the Holy One of Israel.

    Let us briefly glance at the history of the Hebrew people, after their admission to Palestine under Joshua, the successor of Moses. During the life of this faithful leader, they were loyal-hearted and blessed: but after his decease and that of the generation which had been the eye-witness of so many noble manifestations of Almighty Power in their behalf -- their successors through the seducing wiles by which they were beset, fell into a toleration of, and compliance with the idolatrous worship and licentious manners of the surrounding nations.

    This withdrawment from their National Head, who, in delivering them from the tyranny of Egypt, claimed at once their homage as their Creator, Redeemer, Guardian, and Governor, rendered the alienated people at once powerless and defenceless. Again and again, when under oppressive tribute, the spirit of their Judges was stirred up to call upon the LORD for help -- but time obliterated these impressions, and new provocations called forth fresh calamities.

    The rending of the Ten Tribes from the House of David, about seven hundred and forty years before the birth of the




    xvi                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    Messiah, forms a marked epoch in the History of the Hebrews, and ought to be scrupulously attended to in all its aspects and bearings, in order that a correct estimate may be formed of subsequent and yet future events and promises which include "the outcasts of Israel," as well as "the dispersed of Judah."

    The act of rending themselves in a spirit of atheistical democracy from the House of David -- also separated them from the enjoined and indispensable statutes and ordinances which were part and parcel of the Theocratic Law of the Land.

    The next step, for which this disloyalty to their King prepared them, was the substituting of representative objects of worship in direct violation of one of the great commands in the Law. This aggravated departure from the Fountain of Wisdom and Goodness necessarily resulted in demoralization which in its re-action rendered them an easy conquest to the victorious Assyrian, who "plucked them up" out of the soil, transplanted them to the remote provinces of his dominion, and substituted in their stead a mingled colony from various parts of the Assyrian Empire.

    Hosea, a prophet of Samaria, and belonging to the Ten Tribes, had been commissioned to warn and admonish the transgressors before their expatriation; -- fearlessly did he declare the consequences which their disloyalty was preparing for them faithfully did he reproach their ingratitude to Him who had "been an Husband unto them" -- whose constant love and manifold gifts they had repaid with the basest wanderings of their heart and mind after the dumb vanities of the heathen. He is commanded to reprove and warn them by types and signs, religion having become in their minds confounded with visible representations and mediums.




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              xvii


    An adulteress is summoned as the meet representative of their unfaithfulness. The prophet is instructed to call her first child Lo-Ruhama, signifying 'I will no longer have mercy.' The next was to be named Lo-Ammi, -- 'Ye are not my people.' But, as if three millenaries were a parenthesis -- "a little moment," it is added: -- "Yet shall the children of Israel be as the sand on the sea-shore which cannot be numbered nor measured; and it shall come to pass, that in the place where it was said "Ye are not my people," it shall be said unto them "Ye are the sons of the living God," -- then shall the children of Judah and the children "of Israel appoint themselves one Head, and they shall come up out of the land, for great shall be the Day of Jezreel."

    Their guilt is declared, their punishment is determined; but lest they should despair during that long season of banishment -- and lest the nations (whose term of probation it should become) might, in the apparent success and maturity of their schemes, be induced to presume, the entail of the covenant closely follows the sentence of temporary banishment. "She was unconscious that I gave her corn, and wine, and oil, and multiplied the silver and gold wherewith she fabricated Baal. I will destroy her vines and fig-trees, whereof she hath said, these are my rewards which my lovers hath given me." Yet, (centuries being anticipated) it is added, "Behold, I will allure her, bring her into the wilderness, and speak comfortingly unto her, and will give her from thence her vineyards, and the valley of trouble for a door of hope -- and she shall be disciplined there as in the days of her youth; and as in the day when she came up out of the land of Egypt. And in that day thou shalt call ME my Husband, and shalt no more call ME my Lord, for I will take away the name of Balaam (Lord's) out of her mouth, and they shall




    xviii                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    no more be remembered by their names: and I will betroth thee unto ME in faithfulness, and thou shalt know I am the LORD. And I will sow her unto ME in the Land, and I will have mercy upon her that had not received mercy, and I will say to those who were "not My people:" -- "My people," -- and they shall say "MY GOD."

    To the prophet it was again said, "Go still love a woman who is beloved of her friend yet an adulteress, according to the love of the LORD toward the children of Israel, who look to other gods, and love their grape offerings." While to her it was said, "Thou shalt abide for me many days * * * thou shalt not be for another -- so shall I also be for thee." For the children of Israel shall continue many days without King, without Ruler, without sacrifice, and without an image, and without Ephod, and without Teraphim: afterward shall the children of Israel return and seek the LORD God, and David their King, and shall fear the LORD and His goodness in the latter days."

    Notwithstanding that in rending themselves from the House of David, they might be said virtually to have disclaimed and renounced the Messiah to be born from thence: they are graciously assured of their being included in the beneficent result of that atonement which (in being rejected as a Prophet,) He should make as their substitute and surety, and in the mediation which He should effect as their Advocate and Intercessor: -- To which promise the prophet Isaiah thus responds, "All we like sheep have gone astray, and the LORD hath laid upon Him the iniquity of us all."

    In harmony with this testimony, the Good Shepherd declares, "Them also I must briny, and they shall hear My voice, and there shall be one FOLD and one SHEPHERD."

    The adversary of the Messiah, having succeeded in tempting His degenerate people to forsake the Fountain of




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                               xix


    Eternal goodness, in leading them to false objects of worship, and in bringing upon them all the evils which their defenceless condition involved, at length claimed them as the prey of death and the grave. But his dominion is invaded by their Champion, the power with which their transgression had armed him, is contested by that which the personal obedience of the Redeemer wields in their behalf; the armour wherein the enemy trusted is overcome, his plea is silenced, his claim is cancelled, his prey is released, himself is judged and condemned -- yet a little while, and his sentence shall be executed.

    The adversary contended with, and overcame those whom, as the deceiver his temptations had first seduced, and of whom he afterwards became the accuser; but now their Redeemer contends with that enemy; -- his power yields to the higher authority of their RIGHTEOUS representative, who in view of His incarnation and its glorious results, thus testifies; Shall the prey be wrested from the powerful, or the lawful captive delivered? Thus saith the LORD God, even the captives of the powerful shall be released, even the prey of the terrible shall be delivered: I will contend with him that contendeth with thee: I will redeem thy children -- I will ransom them from the power of death -- I will reclaim them from the grave. O death, I will be thy visitation! O grave, I will be thy destruction!

    Thus also are His redeemed taught to identify themselves in the personal death and resurrection of the Messiah. ''Come, let us return unto the LORD, He hath rent and will restore us; He hath smitten, and He will bind our wounds; after two days He will reanimate us, on the third day He will raise us up, and we shall live in His Presence. Then shall we know, in following on to know the LORD, that His going forth is prepared as the day-spring, and unto us shall He come as the latter, and as the former rain unto the Land."




    xx                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    Thus were those who were afar off, by a NEW and LIVING way brought nigh -- even into the presence of their reconciled Father in the person of their risen Advocate and Intercessor, whose resurrection became the earnest and pledge of theirs. The miseries of exile, -- the powerless degradation of a scarcely tolerated existence among the adverse interests of hostile nations, had taught the outcasts of Israel a bitter but salutary lesson: -- that the 'vain devices,' on whom they had bestowed those affections of the heart which were due to their Creator and Saviour, could not help them in time of need. They now felt and acknowledged, that regard to these false objects had been the cause of all that calamity in which they were steeped: -- for now, they who had once been the freemen of no mean city, were cast forth dishonoured and powerless amongst the nations who treated with mockery and derision their forfeited preeminence.

    Under such circumstances, it were not wonderful to find them so cured of artificial substitutes, as to loathe the very sight of those idol rites to which their dwelling among the Assyrian idolaters subjected them; and that desirous of shunning all intercourse themselves, and anxious that their posterity should be out of the influence of this seducing and mortal sin which had brought upon them the fierce indignation of their constant Benefactor, that they should form the resolution of withdrawing from the neighbourhood of the Assyrian empire, to some seclusion to which they might be graciously directed in the prosecution of their penitent enterprise, -- for in their darkest season, hope still spake of future Promise. This is not suppositions; a valuable fragment of sacred history, and the last notice on record of the Ten Tribes after their expatriation is at once graphic and explicit. -- 2 Esdras xiii. 14.




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                               xxi


    The Assyrian empire is involved in an obscurity to which the change of the names of places has chiefly contributed. In the absence of intermediate historical lights, it becomes especially needful in the investigation of so grave a subject as that under review, to recur to those enduring land-marks and characteristics which have been preserved in that History, which amid the fluctuating experience of the kingdoms of this world remains unalterably the same.

    Two circumstances are to be noted as a key to succeeding events. The first is, that in the original division of territory, the whole of that through which the expatriated tribes passed on their migration to the New Continent, had been appointed to Asshur, the son of the patriarch Shem; although it had been subsequently invaded and usurped by Nimrod, the son of Cush. Hence the Assyrian empire, from having originally received the name of Asshur, retained that name; although it is also made mention of as Cush, which is generally translated Ethiopia.

    It appears that the Assyrian empire was of short duration after the reign of Esar-haddon; and that a great portion of the Hebrews continued to sojourn in the provinces of Media Persia, and Tartary. The first invasion of the Assyrian monarch Tiglath-pileser, was B.C. 740; by him the inhabitants of Gallilee -- the tribes of Reuben, Naphtali, Gad, and the half tribe of Manassah were made captive, and carried to the provinces of Media. The second invasion by Shalmanezer, was nineteen years afterwards, and this captivity, like the former, was placed in Halah and Habor, by the river Gozan. The third conquest, that of Samaria, was by Esar-haddon, B.C. 678, in which the remainder of the Ten Tribes, with the exception, according to Josephus, of about 600, were carried into the land of Assyria, and it is probable that these last exiles smarting under recent infliction,




    xxii                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    and not as those who had preceded them in any respect, attached by domestic ties to the soil, formed that body which came to the determination of "leaving the multitude of the heathen to go into a remote country wherein never had mankind dwelt that they might there keep their statutes which they had never observed in their own Land, and there was a great way to go, namely a year and a half, and that region is called Arsareth" (Armenia.)

    Doctor Elias Boudinot thus writes. "The country into which the Ten Tribes were thus transplanted, was very thinly inhabited and extended farther north than we have any idea of. Those captive Israelites must have greatly increased in numbers before their migration more northward and westward; this is confirmed by the names of cities which to this day bear the names of their founders. Samarcand plainly derived from Samaria; they have a city on a hill called Mount Tabor. A city built on the river Ardon, is named Jericho, which river runs near the Caspian sea upon the north east. There are two cities called Chorazin, the great and the less. The Tartar chiefs are called Morsoyes which closely resembles Moses.

    The Tartars boast their descent from the Israelites, and the famous Tamerlane, [1] (or Timur,) took a pride in declaring that he descended from the tribe of Dan. Vide note in p 162, Star of the West.

    The author of Historical Researches has traced many remarkable analogies between the Mogul and Tartar tribes, and those of the Western hemisphere; with respect to the conquests of the Mogul, he observes, 'All the continent of

    __________
    1 The author of Hist. Resear. p. 12, gives from Timour's Institutes, the following characteristic sentiment: 'If the canopy of heaven were a bow, and the earth the cord thereof; and if calamities were the arrows, and if Almighty God, -- the tremendous and the glorious, were the unerring archer, to whom would the sons of Adam flee for protection? The sons of Adam must flee unto the LORD.'




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                               xxiii


    Asia, except Hindostan and Arabia, was subdued in 1280, (Hindostan was invaded by Timour, but not possessed by the Moguls till 1025); he adds, we must fully acquiesce in the truth of the remark of the eloquent Gibbon, that the rapid conquests of the Moguls and Tartars, may be compared with the primitive convulsions of nature, which have agitated and altered the surface of the globe.'

    Josephus, the Historian, makes mention of the Ten Tribes as then being 'somewhere beyond the Euphrates;' and calls them Adiabaniens. [1] Other Jewish historians relate that they were carried, not only into Media and Persia, but into 'the northern countries beyond the Bosphorus.' Ortelius speaks of them as being in Tartary. Herodotus affirms that the Scythians, (whom Bryant supposed derived their name from Cush or Cutha,) conquered the Empire of Media, in Upper Asia, soon after the expulsion of the last portion of the Ten Tribes from Palestine. Herodotus, lib. i. c. 157. Prideaux, i. 25-356.

    Scythia was the ancient name given to Tartary, which extended from the mouth of the Obey in Russia, to the Dnipier, from thence to the Euxine sea -- thence along the foot of Mount Caucasus, by the rivers Kur and Aras, to the Caspian Sea -- thence by the White mountains, including part of Russia, with the districts that lie between the frozen and Japan seas. [2] Sir William Jones, Disser. vol. i. p. 142, &c.

    __________
    1 From the mouth of the Danube, to the sea of Japan, the whole longitude of Scythia is about one hundred and ten degrees, which in that parallel are equal to zzz1 The river Lyens, which runs a little west of Hala, was anciently called Zeba, or Diava, by Ammianus, which signifies a wolf; whence this portion of Assyria was called Adiabane, and the river Lyens was called sometime Ahavah, (love) or Adiabane. It may cast some light on this subject to know that Josephus, in his Antiquities, book xx. chap. v. says, that Helena, queen of Adiabane, who had embraced the Jewish religion, sent some of her servants to Alexandria, to buy a great quantity of corn; and others of them to Cyprus, to buy a cargo of dried figs, which she distributed to the Jews that were in want. This was in the time of the famine, mentioned by Agabus, Acts xi. 28, and took place in A. D. 47, or thereabouts. This shows that there were many Jews in that country.

    2 From the mouth of the Danube, to the sea of Japan, the whole longitude of Scythia is about one hundred and ten degrees, which in that parallel are equal to




    xxiv                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    "The Caspian or Circasian Straits, through the mountain of Caucasus, lies about midway between the Euxine sea to the west, and the Caspian sea to the east, through Iberia. After passing through the Strait on the north, keeping a little westward, you pass on in the neighbourhood of the Euxine Sea through Armenia Minor, into Syria Proper, and by the head of the Mediterranean Sea to Palestine, without crossing the Euphrates. But all who are in Persia, in Armenia Major, and in the eastward of Mesopotamia and beyond Babylon, must pass the Euphrates to get there." -- Star in the West, page 167.

    Giles Fletcher, LL.D. in his treatise, printed in 1667, observes: -- "as for two of these Colonies of the Samaritan Israelites, carried off by Salmanassar, which were placed in Harak [1] and Harbor, they bordered both on the Medians (where the others were ordered on the north and north-east of the Caspian Sea, a barren country.) So that those tribes might easily meet and join together when opportunity served their turn, which happened unto them not long after, when all the provinces of Media, Chaldaran, and Mesopotamia with their rulers, Merodach, and Baladan, and Dejoces, called in Scripture Arphaxad, by desertion fell away from the Assyrians in the tenth year of Esar-haddon, and that these tribes did not long after re-unite themselves and join in one nation." Doctor Boudinot observes, "They

    __________
    five thousand miles. The latitude reaches from the fortieth degree, which touches the wall of China above one thousand miles northward to the frozen regions of Siberia. -- Robertson's View of the Progress of Society in Europe, p. 335.

    1 "Harrah, or as it is called by some, Hara, which in Hebrew signifies bitter, is the root from whence it is used to signify a mountainous tract, and thus gave that name to the country north of Assyria, near to Media, which perhaps ran through it. On the north of this tract runs the river Araxis, now called Aras. Obarius, 296. Obarius, on whom much dependence may be placed, describes the source of the river Araxis to be ill the mountains of Ararat, of Armenia, so that Harah is no other than the province of Iran, situate between the rivers Charboras or Araxis, as it is called in the Anabasis of Xenophon and Cyrus, now called Aras and Kur." Star in the West.




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                               xxv


    must have known the success of the Scythians, then the Medes, and then the Persians under Cyrus, which was followed by the easy conquest of the whole of Media and Persia, as Herodotus has shewn in his history, and by which they must have been encouraged in so important a business. The power of the kingdom was also comparatively weak, at so great a distance from the capital, and distracted with political cabals and insurrections against Astigages, who reigned over both Media and Persia, and who was conquered by his grandson Cyrus. And it is not improbable but that a removal more north, by which such restless subjects would leave their improvements and real property to the other inhabitants, and extend the territory of their governors, would not have been disagreeable either to the princes or people of that country. Again, "the usual route from the Euxine sea to the northward of the Caspian sea, through Tartary and Scythia, to Serica and the northern parts of China, by which the merchants carried on a great trade, might enable the tribes to travel northward and eastward, towards Kamschatka. At least this is the assertion of that able geographer D'Anville, in his ancient geography, written before the late discoveries of Cook and others." -- Vol. ii. p. 521--523.

    "But the most minute and last account we have of them, is in the thirteenth chapter of the second book of Esdras."

    "These Israelites, then, accordingly executed their purpose, and left their place of banishment in a body, although it is hardly to be doubted but some, comparatively few, from various motives, as before observed, remained behind; although their places may have been filled up by many natives, who might prefer taking their chance with them in their emigrations, which were common to the people




    xxvi                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    of that region, especially the old inhabitants of Damascus removed to the river Ker by Tiglath Pilezer, some time before the taking of Samaria, and the removal of the ten tribes. They proceeded till they came to a great water or river, which stopped their progress, as they had no artificial means of passing it, and reduced them to great distress and almost despair. How long they remained here, cannot now be known; but finally, God again appeared for them, as he had done for their fathers of old at the Red Sea, by giving them some token of His presence, and encouraging them to go on; thus countenancing them in their project of forsaking the heathen." Star in the West.

    The Historical Records of the transatlantic people are to authenticate this migration through Asia, as well as the expectation of a Redeemer, and that redemption of their bodies, from the power of the grave, which the prophets ascribe to Him, and which was the Hope of Israel.

    The events which are to fulfil this expectation being represented as simultaneous, and at the close of 'the times of the gentiles,' -- or end of the existing world or age, the following extracts from this page of future history, come home with all the weight and power of that Truth to which all must sooner or later - - willingly or unwillingly bow.

    The deliverance from Egypt was altogether prefigurative of that ultimate redemption, which at His second coming, shall crown the travail of the Messiah's soul; hence it is said, "Behold the days come when it shall no more be said, the LORD liveth who brought up the children of Israel from the land of Egypt; but the LORD liveth that brought up the children of Israel from the Land of the north; and from all the lands whither he had driven them; and I will bring them unto their own Land, that I gave to their fathers. Behold, I will send for many fishers, and they shall fish them; and




                                PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                             xxvii


    for many hunters, and they shall hunt them; * * * Therefore I will make them to know at that time -- I will cause them to know Mine hand and My power, and they shall know that My Name is JEHOVAH." "Remember not the former doings, neither revolve the acts of old times, Behold, I will do a new thing; now shall it begin -- and shall ye not know it? I will even make a way in the wilderness, and give rivers in the desert. The wild beasts shall reverence Me, the ostrich, and the daughters of the owl, because I give water-springs in the wilderness, and streams in the desert to refresh My people. My chosen. This people I have formed for Myself, they shall manifest My glory."

    The prophet Ezekiel thus characterises the same place and people. "As I live, saith the Lord God, assuredly with a strong hand and an extended arm, and with ardent zeal will I govern you, and I will bring you out from the peoples, and will gather you out from the countries wherein ye are scattered, and I will bring you unto the wilderness of the people, and there will I plead with you face to face, like as I pleaded with your ancestors in the wilderness of the land of Egypt; thus will I admonish you, saith the Lord God, and I will cause you to pass under the rod, and will bring you under the obligation (fetter) of the covenant; and I will purge out from among you the rebellious, and those who transgress against Me. I will bring them forth out of the countries where they sojourn; and they shall not enter into the Land of Israel: and ye shall know that I am YEHOVAH."

    The prophet Hosea testifies to the same prospective experience. "Therefore, behold, I will allure her, and bring her into the wilderness, and speak comfortingly unto her, and will give her vineyards from thence, and the valley of tribulation for a door of Hope; and she shall be taught there,




    xxviii                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    as in the days of her youth, as in the days when I brought her up out of the land of Egypt. And it shall be in that Day, saith the Lord, thou shalt call Me my Husband, and shalt no more call me my Lord. And I will betroth thee unto Me in righteousness, and in justice, and in loving- kindness, and in mercies. I will even betroth thee unto Me in faithfulness; and thou shalt know the LORD." "And it shall come to pass in that day, that the LORD shall smite off from the channel of the river unto the stream of Egypt, and ye shall be gathered one by one, O ye children of Israel. And that day the great trumpet shall be blown, and they shall come who were ready to perish in the land of Assyria, and the outcasts in the land of Egypt, and shall worship YEHOVAH in the holy mountain at Jerusalem." On this passage much additional light is reflected by the words of the Divine prophet. "And He shall send His angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together His chosen from the four winds, from one extreme under Heaven to the other." The generation which should live to see the first symptoms of returning life in the long dormant vine of Israel, and fig-tree of Judah, shall also see its fruition. "This generation," (said He of those who shall see these things begin to come to pass,) "shall not pass away till all be accomplished."

    "And God said unto Jacob, arise and go to Bethel, and sojourn there; and build there an altar unto God, who appeared unto thee when thou didst flee from the face of thy brother." "The Land which I gave to Abraham and Isaac, to thee will I give it, and to thy seed after thee will I give the Land." In blessing the two sons of Joseph, Israel thus testified of their prospective inheritance." God Almighty, who appeared unto me in Luz, in the land of Canaan, blessed me, and said unto me, Behold, I will make thee fruitful,




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              xxix


    and multiply thee, and will make of thee a multitude of nations, and will give this Land unto thy seed after thee, for an everlasting possession; and now thy two sons Ephraim and Manasseh, who were born unto thee in Egypt before I came thither unto thee, shall be mine -- as Reuben [1] and Simeon shall they be to me." "And he blessed Joseph and said, God, before whom my fathers Abraham and Isaac did walk -- the God who sustained me all my life unto this day -- the angel who redeemed me from all evil, bless the youths, and let my name be named upon them, and the names of my fathers Abraham and Isaac, and let them increase into a multitude in the midst of the earth. Moreover I have given to thee one portion above thy brethren, which I won out of the hand of the Amorite with my sword and with my Bow."

    The portion to which allusion is here made, was prospective, even as the weapons are emblematical of that faith by which Israel laid hold of the Word of God, and that prayer by which he appropriated His promises. In the blessing which the dying patriarch gave to Joseph, the same Bow is alluded to in the hand of Joseph. "Joseph is a fruitful branch, a fruitful branch to look upon, whose off-shoots extend over the wall; with bitter pride they (the adversaries) shot at him, but his Bow abode in strength; and the power of his hands continued strong by the hands (oversight) of the Omnipotent of Israel, from whom is the Shepherd, the Gem of Israel -- even by the God of thy fathers, who shall help thee; and by the Almighty who shall bless thee with the blessings of Heaven above, -- the blessings of the abyss that lieth under -- the blessing of the fields and of the womb. The blessings of thy father have prevailed unto the utmost

    __________
    1 The portion of the first born (a double portion) having been forfeited by Reuben, was given to the tribe of Ephraim.




    xxx                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    bounds of the enduring mountains, they shall continue on the head of Joseph, and on the crown of the separated from his brethren."

    Moses prospectively characterizes the tribe of Ephraim in his blessing upon Joseph, in language almost identical; "And of Joseph, he said, Blessed of the LORD be his land for the precious gifts of Heaven, for the dew and for the void place (abyss) that coucheth beneath. For the precious gifts brought forth by the sun, and for the precious things put forth by the moon; and for the chief things of the enduring mountains and for the precious things of the eternal high places; for the precious things of the earth in its fulness, -- His favour that dwelt in the thorn-bush continues on the head of Joseph: and on the crown of the separated from his brethren."

    This language is peculiarly significant, when it is recollected that Ephraim was the crowned head, to whom, in its extension, the blessing was directed.

    The secluded tribes are by the prophet Isaiah thus graphically characterized: Ho! to the land of quivering wings, which is beyond the river of Cush, that sendeth messengers by sea, in light vessels upon the face of the waters, saying, Go ye swift messengers to an extended nation, whose land has been meted out and trodden under foot -- to a people terrible before and since -- a people of strength, meted out and trodden down, whose land the rivers [1] have invaded: [2] All the dwellers upon earth, and the inhabitants of the land when He lifteth up a signal upon the mountains 'behold,' and when He bloweth the trumpet 'listen,' for thus the LORD said to me. I will remain quiet (be inactive.) I will observe in My dwelling place in still warmth, (serene heat)

    __________
    1 [Hebrew word] used metaphorically of the confluence and inundation of nations.

    2 root is booty, or prey,




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              xxxi


    as the Light at a threshold, [1] and as the dew upon the harvest field; for before the harvest when the blossom is full, and the embryo grape is ripening in the flower, he shall both cut off the twigs with knives, and lop off the branches. They shall be left together, unto the fowls of the mountain, and to the ravening beasts of the earth; the fowls shall harvest upon them, and the beast of the earth shall winter upon them. At that time shall be brought to the LORD of hosts as a costly present; a people terrible and far removed -- a nation meted out and trampled under foot, whose land the rivers have spoiled, to the appointed Place, to the Land of the dwelling Place of the Name of the LORD of hosts, the Mount Zion.' Isaiah xviii. The image of quivering or fluttering wings, seems to be descriptive of the expecting attitude of the people to whom the allusion is made; as doves plume and put in motion their pinions preparatory to an expected flight; in this beautiful attitude they are also characterized by David. 'Although ye have been hid in the stalls (places in the suburbs where sacrificial victims were penned) as the wings of a dove, radiant as silver, and gleaming as gold, shall ye come forth.' This applies to the identical period and event, of which Mount Zion shall be the scene. 'Wherefore do ye contend, ye high mountains? This is the Mountain in which God desireth to dwell, yea, Yehovah shall dwell there for ever.' 'The LORD said, I will bring again My people from Bashan, I will bring also from the seclusion beyond sea.' 'Princes shall come forth from Egypt, Cush shall speedily stretch forth her hands unto God.' Psalm Ixviii. 13, 22, 31.

    The prophet Isaiah adopts the same imagery, "Who are these that fly as a cloud, and as doves to their windows?

    __________
    1 [Hebrew word] an architectural expression -- the colonnade or entrance to a Temple.




    xxxii                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    Surely the islands shall attend upon Me, and the ships of Tarshish first, to bring thy sons from afar, their silver and their gold with them, unto the Name of YEHOVAH thy God, and unto the Holy Israelite, for He hath glorified thee," Isaiah Ix. 8, 9. "In that Day there shall be a Branch from the Root of Jesse, to Him shall the nations seek, and His liest shall be glorious. And it shall be in that Day, that the LORD shall put to His Hand a second time to Redeem the remnant of His people which shall remain, from Assyria, and from Egypt, from Pathros, from Cush, from Elam, from Shinar, from Hamath, and from the islands of the sea. And He shall set up a standard for the nations, and He shall assemble the banished of Israel, and gather the dispersed of Judah from the four extremes (wings) of the earth." "And the Lord shall utterly cut off the tongue of the Egyptian sea, and with a mighty wind shall He shake His Hand over the river, and shall smite it in the seven streams, and men shall walk over in their shoes, and there shall be an high-way for the remnant of His people which shall be left from Assyria, like as there was to Israel in the day that they came up out of the land of Egypt." Isaiah xi.

    It is to be noted that during his natural life, Abraham possessed only one field which he purchased of the sons of Heth: -- and yet it was said to Abraham, I will give unto thee, and to thy seed after thee, the Land wherein thou art a stranger -- all the Land of Canaan for an everlasting possession, and I will be their God." Gen. xvii. 8.

    Accordingly, when Sarah died, Abraham stood up from before his dead, and thus spake to the sons of Heth. "I am a stranger and sojourner with you, give me possession of a burying-place with you that I may bury my dead out of my sight."

    The martyr Stephen is peculiarly explicit respecting the




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                             xxxiii


    prospective inheritance: "He gave him (Abraham) none inheritance in it -- no, not so much as to set his foot on; yet He promised that He would give it to him for an inheritance. and to his seed after him, when as yet he had no child." Acts vii. 5.

    Jacob had also only one field in the Land wherein he was a stranger, which he purchased from the sons of Hamor, and which is thus recognized in after times, "Then cometh he to a city of Samaria (Sychar) near to the parcel of ground that Jacob gave to his son Joseph -- now Jacob's well was there."

    In like manner, as a memorial or pledge of future possession at the very time when Jerusalem was besieged by the king of Babylon, and when Jeremiah the prophet was shut up in the court of the king's prison, because of the faithfulness of his testimony -- even then, although he should never return from that captivity, he was commanded to purchase a field. The prophet was amazed at the command: until Hanameel offered to sell him the field, the right of redemption being his. "Then I knew that it was the Word of the LORD, and I bought the field of Hanameel that was in Anathoth, and weighed him the money, seventeen shekels of silver; and I subscribed the evidence, and took witnesses, and weighed the money in the balances; and I took the evidence of the purchase, us well that which was sealed as that which was open."

    "Thus saith the LORD of hosts, the God of Israel, Take these evidences of the purchase, as well that which is sealed, as that which is open, and put them in an earthen vessel, that they may continue many days. For thus saith the LORD of hosts, Houses, and fields, and vineyards shall be repossessed in this Land."

    Jeremiah thus despondingly pleads: "Behold the engines




    xxxiv                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    are brought unto the city, and the city is given into the hands of the Chaldeans, who fight against it in the midst of sword and famine and pestilence, and what thou hast said has come to pass, and Thou beholdest! -- yet, O LORD God, thou hast said to me, Buy thee a field for money, and take witnesses, although the city is given into the hands of the Chaldeans. Then came the Word of the LORD to Jeremiah, saying, Behold I am the LORD, the God of all flesh: Is there anything too hard for Me? * * *

    "Behold I will gather them out of all countries whither I have driven them in mine anger and in mine indignation: and I will bring them again unto THIS PLACE, and will cause them to dwell securely; and they shall be My people, and I will be their God; and I will give them one heart and one WAY, that they may reverence ME constantly for the good of them, and of their children after them, and I will make an everlasting covenant with them in stability, to endure for their good; and I will put My fear in their hearts that they shall not depart from Me; yea, I will rejoice over them to do them good, and I will plant them in this LAND of a truth with My whole heart and with My whole soul. For thus saith the LORD, Even as I have brought all this great evil upon this people, so will I bring upon them all the good that I have promised them; and fields shall be bought in this LAND (whereof ye say it is desolate without man and beast, it is given unto the hands of the Chaldeans) men shall buy fields for money and subscribe evidences, and seal them, and take witness in all the places around Jerusalem, for I will cause their captivity to return, saith the LORD." Jeremiah xxii.

    In like manner it was said to Daniel, 'Go thy way and repose till the end, for thou shalt stand up in thy lot at the end of the days. The call again is to the land of wings. Ho!




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              xxxv


    Ho! fly from the land of the north, for, saith the LORD, I have spread you abroad as the four winds of Heaven, saith the LORD. Save yourselves from the daughter of Babel, for thus saith the LORD of Hosts, after the glory, He sendeth me to the nations which spoiled you, for they that injure you, touch the apple of His eyes. For behold, I will shake Mine hand upon them, and they shall be for a spoil to their servants, and ye shall know that the LORD of hosts hath sent Me. Sing and rejoice, O daughter of Zion: for behold I come, and I will dwell in the midst of thee, saith the LORD, and many nations shall become united to YEHOVAH in that day, and shall be My people; and I will dwell in the midst of thee, and thou shalt know that the LORD of hosts hath sent Me unto thee. And the LORD shall inherit JUDAH His portion in the Holy Land, and shall again choose JERUSALEM. Be still, O all flesh before the LORD, for He is roused from His Habitation of Holiness.

    "Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion, shout O daughter of Jerusalem, behold thy King cometh unto thee, just and gracious, humbly carried upon an ass, and upon a colt the foal of an ass. And I will take away the war chariot from Ephraim, and the war-horse from Jerusalem, and the battle- bow shall be unstrung, and he shall speak peace to the nations, and His dominion shall be from sea to sea, from the river (Euphrates) to the ends of the earth: -- as for thee also, whose covenant is by blood, I have released thy prisoners from the abyss wherein is no water. Turn you to the strong hold, ye captives of Hope, even in this day do I declare that I will render precious gifts double unto thee. When I have bent Judah for Me, and filled My Bow with Ephraim, and raised up thy sons, O Zion, against thy sons, O Greece, and made thee as the warriors' sword, and the LORD shall be seen over them, and His arrow shall go forth




    xxxvi                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    as lightning, and the LORD God shall sound the trumpet (of Jubilee,) and shall go amid whirlwinds of the south. And the LORD God shall save thee in that Day, even the flock of His people, for they shall be as the gems of a crown, lifted up as an ensign upon His Land. I will strengthen the House of Judah, and I will redeem the House of Joseph, and I will bring them to establish them, for I have mercy upon them, and they shall be as though I had not banished them; for I am the LORD their God, and will hear them. And they of Ephraim shall be conquerors, their heart shall rejoice as with wine; yea, their children shall see it and be glad; their heart shall rejoice in the LORD. I will hiss to them and gather them, for I have redeemed them, and they shall increase as they have increased, and I will sow them in peoples, and they shall remember me in far countries, and they shall live, and with their children, return again. And I will bring them a second time out of the land of Egypt, and gather them from Assyria, and I will bring them unto the country of Gilead and Lebanon, and place shall not be found for them. And he shall pass through the waters with affliction, and shall smite the waves in the sea, and all the deeps of the river (Euphrates) shall be dried up; and the pride of Assyria shall be humbled, and the dominion of Egypt shall cease, and I will strengthen them in the LORD, they shall walk hither and thither in His Name, saith Yehovah."

    The preceding considerations teach us to expect that the sons of Joseph have become in their seclusion as the countless stars, 'a multitude of nations,' not only on the earth, but expecting (in the place of separate spirits,) the voice which shall restore to them at once their redeemed bodies and inheritance. They who are alive and remain at the coming of the LORD, (whose voice shall call forth the prisoners of




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                            xxxvii


    hope from their concealment,) shall not prevent those who are asleep. Such as (like the Sadducees of old,) have explained away to a shadowy abstraction the resurrection of the body can form a very inadequate idea of the substance and locality which this most heart-cheering truth afforded to Abraham, and the heirs of those promises which in their redeemed bodies should be fulfilled to them. They did not view the age or world to come, as invisible in the sense of being immaterial and impalpable; to their mind it was invisible only in the manner that the celestial luminaries are so, when for a season hid by the intervention of dense clouds and smoke. Their faith supplied the place of vision, for they knew that in reality and substance, a KINGDOM and KING were in reserve, and should visibly appear when the Roman Empire (the last of the four interposing Monarchies) shall have, like those which it supplanted, in turn become the subject of that dissolution to which all that is in opposition to the Law of God is destined.

    Again, to Jacob the promised Land was confirmed, when the LORD appeared as the Head of that mystic ladder, which resting upon earth should, (as a type of the Messiah,) become the medium of restored communion between Heaven and earth, "I am the LORD God of Abraham thy father, and of Isaac -- the Land whereon thou liest, to thee will I give it, and to thy seed, and thine offspring shall be as the dust of the ground, and thou shalt spread abroad to the west, and to the east, and to the north, and to the south; and in thee, and in thy seed shall all the families of the earth be blessed. And behold I am with thee, and will preserve thee in all places whither thou goest, and will bring thee again to this Land, for I will not forsake thee until I have accomplished that which I have declared." A series of ages having elapsed, the house of Israel is described as tacitly saying,




    xxxviii                             PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                            


    "behold our bones are dead, and our hope is gone, for we are cut off from our parts." "Thus saith the LORD God, Behold, O My people, I will open your graves, and bring you unto the LAND of Israel; and ye shall know that I am YEHOVAH, When I have opened your graves, O My people, and have redeemed you out of your graves; and shall put My Spirit within you, and ye shall live, and I shall restore you to your own Land: then ye shall know that I the LORD have spoken and performed, saith the LORD."

    David beautifully compares this resurrection-Day to the dew of the morning: "From the womb of the morning shall appear the dew of thy bringing-forth."

    It should be determined what is the nature of redeemed existence -- of incorruptible and glorious bodies, before it is asked how the limits of the promised Land can contain the myriads who shall make good the promises there for a Thousand yours, before a still progressive state is entered upon. Upon Mount Zion alone were prospectively seen, 144,000 of the Twelve Tribes, and with them a great multitude of those from among the Gentiles who had chosen the better portion -- thus having been made meet for the inheritance of the holy ones in Light. Revelation vii.

    The Prophet Isaiah testifies to this comforting Truth which the characterizes as "The Hope" of Israel. Acts xxvi. 6. "Thou hast increased the nation O LORD, thou art glorified! LORD, in trouble they have besought thee, they poured out a secret prayer when Thy chastening was upon them." Thy dead shall revive -- with My dead body shall they arise. Awake, rejoicing, ye that dwell in the dust; for as the dew to the light, so is thy dew, for the earth shall yield up the preserved (praying). And it shall come to pass in that Day, the Lord shall smite off 'from the channel of the river (Euphrates) unto the river of Egypt, and ye shall be gathered one




                                  PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                            xxxix


    by one, O ye children of Israel, and in that Day the great (Jubilee) trumpet shall be sounded, and they shall come who were ready to perish in the land of Assyria, and the outcasts in the land of Egypt and shall worship the LORD in the holy Mountain at Jerusalem.

    Of this grand ultimate convocation, the Apostle Paul thus speaks: "Now we entreat you, brethren, by the coming of our LORD Jesus Christ, and by our gathering together unto Him." * * * "The LORD Himself shall descend from Heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet of God, and the dead in Christ shall rise first."

    It was by His bodily restoration to renewed life that the promises to the fathers became confirmed, His reanimated body being the earnest and pledge of those of His redeemed. Hence His rejection in His office of Prophet by that remnant of the two tribes (which remained after the building of the second Temple,) constituted Him the atonement for the whole -- whether present or absent, as also in design for the whole world.

    It was of the result which His atonement should accomplish, that the Great Shepherd of the flock thus spake: "Other sheep I have which are not of this fold, them also I must bring (again) and they shall hear My voice" (as Lazarus had heard it) "and there shall be one Fold and one Shepherd." The prophet Ezekiel gives this piece of future history in detail: "Thus saith the LORD God, Behold I will take the children of Israel from among the nations, whither they are gone and will gather them on all sides, and bring them into their own LAND; and I will make them one nation in the LAND upon the mountains of Israel; and one King shall be King to them all; they shall no more be two nations, neither shall they be divided into two kingdoms any more for ever;




    xl                               PRELIMINARY  OBSERVATIONS.                              


    neither shall they defile themselves any more with their idols, nor with their detestable things, nor with any of their transgressions; for I will redeem them out of their dwelling-places wherein they have sinned, and will purify them; so shall they be My people, and I will be their God, and David My servant shall be King over them, and they shall all have one Shepherd; they shall also walk in My judgments and observe My statutes and do them; and they shall dwell in the Land that I have given unto Jacob My servant, wherein your fathers have sojourned, and they dwell therein they and their children's children for ever; and My servant David shall be their Prince for evermore. My Tabernacle also shall be with them; yea, I will be their God, and they shall be My people; and the nations shall know that I, JEHOVAH, do sanctify Israel, when MY SANCTUARY shall be in the midst of them for ever."



     

    [ 1 ]




    PRELIMINARY  NOTICES
    OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.


    In order to form a just estimate of the value of testimony, it is necessary to obtain some knowledge of those who record it, since respectability and authentic sources of information constitute their claim to the attention and regard of the reader. The duration of their sojourn, their perfect knowledge of the language, records, and antiquities of the people, whose manners and customs they narrate, as well as the relative circumstances in which themselves were placed, and the interests with which they were connected, are all to be taken into consideration. The Spanish Historians, whose names frequently occur in this work, were all members of the Romish communion, the greater part ecclesiastics, and, as their names indicate, chiefly of Hebrew descent.

    Those early Spanish writers, unanimously recognized and acknowledged the manifold analogies which demonstrate the transference of the Levitical economy to the New Continent; but while some of them discerned in this circumstance an indisputable proof of the Hebrew origin of the newly-discovered People; others accounted for this almost fac-simile resemblance by asserting that Satan had counterfeited in this People, (whom he had chosen for himself,) the history, manners, customs, traditions, and expectations of the Hebrews, in order that their




    2                                                PRELIMINARY  NOTICES.                                               


    minds might thus be rendered inaccessible to the faith which he foresaw the church would in due time introduce amongst them!

    The Historians who ranked themselves as the advocates of the former of these alternatives, were LAS CASAS, SAHAGUN, BOTURINI, GARCIA, GUMILLA, BENAVENTA, and MARTYR. Those who maintained the latter hypothesis were TORQUEMEDA, HERRERA, GOMARA, D'ACOSTA, CORTEZ, D'OLMES, DIAZ. The circumstances in which Herrera and Gomara were placed, (the former having been Royal Historiographer, and the latter Chaplain to Cortez,) admitted of their taking only the orthodox view of the subject. The "secret correspondence" of Cortez with Charles V. together with the rigorous censorship which was exercised by 'the holy tribunal,' sufficiently prove that even this least offensive view of the subject was to be expressed with reserve. [1]

    The testimony of writers who rejected the evidence of those facts which they nevertheless admitted and recorded, is peculiarly valuable, since the reader of the eighteenth century is more likely to draw conclusions from these admitted facts, than to assume that hypothesis which left them at liberty to acknowledge them as such.

    __________
    1 "The secret correspondence of Cortez with the Spanish court, which probably still exists, either in the archives of Simancha, or the Escurial, would, if ever published, throw great light on a mystery which religious and state policy kept concealed. Peter Martyr does not refer to two or three letters ofthat conqueror, but to "a huge volume," which was laid before the council of the Indies, of which Garcia de Loisa (the Emperor's confessor) was president, and both he and Gomara (who was Chaplain to Cortez,) confess that they have imposed reserve upon themselves, in treating of the Mexican superstitions." -- Antiq. Mex. fol. vi. page 329.




                                                  OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.                                               3


    DON  BARTHOLOMEW  LAS  CASAS.

    "That [1] Las Casas was firmly persuaded that the Indians were descended from the Hebrews, is evident from his own words, [2] "Loquela tua manifestum te fecit, your speech betrays you," as recorded by Torquemeda. If the work of that illustrious prelate, (who was intimately acquainted with Columbus, whose life he wrote, and who was one of the first Spaniards who proceeded to the continent of America, where he must have had an opportunity of becoming acquainted with the traditions, &c.) had ever been published, we should have known his reasons for coming to that conclusion: that bishop was too rational to adopt the hypothesis embraced by Acosta and Torquemeda, that the Devil had actually counterfeited the history, laws, rites, ceremonies, and customs of the Jews in the New World, but he believed that the Hebrews had colonized America."

    __________
    1 Bartolome Las Casas, a famous Dominican Spaniard, first bishop of Chiapa, and highly worthy of memorial among the Indians. The bitter memorials presented by this excellent prelate to King Charles V., and Philip II., in favour of the Indians against the Spaniards, printed in Seville, and afterwards translated and reprinted in odium to the Spaniards, into several European languages, contains some particulars of the ancient history of the Mexicans. He wrote other works, one a General History of America, in 3 vols. folio. Two volumes are in the celebrated Archives Simancas, which have been the sepulchre of many precious Manuscripts on America. Clavegero Disser. The remonstrance of Las Casas, see Appendix.

    2 "The words 'loquela tua manifestum te fecit,' in reference to the Mexicans and other Indian tribes, whom he took to be real Hebrews, deserve the must serious attention, because we have here the opinion of a person who was well acquainted with the Mexicans and Peruvians, and who proceeded to America immediately after its discovery by the Spaniards, spent there the greater part of a long life, and solemnly recorded in a testamentary document, his conviction of a fact which he might have had many reasons for not choosing to divulge." Antiq. Mex. p. 331. ("Las Casas even goes so far as to say that the language of the Island of St. Domingo was corrupt Hebrew." Ibid.) "At the same time that great credit must be attached to so solemnly-recorded an opinion, it cannot be said that the learned prelate was guilty of any indiscretion in promulgating it; but the contrary is proved by the proviso which he made respecting the publication of his history -- that it should not be printed till fifty years after his death; this work was never published, and Don M. F. Navarette says, that when it was referred some years ago to the Academy of History at Madrid, to take their decision respecting its publication, they did not think it convenient." -- Ibid.




    4                                                PRELIMINARY  NOTICES.                                               


    "The observation which we have made above, that the ecclesiastics were not encouraged to communicate what they knew from intercourse with the natives and the perfect knowledge which they had acquired of the Mexican language, and of the religion and antiquities of the American natives is as strange as that the American Chronicle of Las Casas and the Universal History of New Spain by Sahagun, should never have been published. The former of these works must have been of enormous magnitude, if we may judge of the size of the whole, from only having seen that part of it which is preserved in the British Museum, which includes the preface to the first books. Las Casas explains in the preface, which is very long, the reasons which induced him to undertake the work, which were primarily of a religious nature, although it would appear that he was also desirous of opposing a true history to the many false relations and misrepresentations which he complains that writers on the affairs of America had unblushingly published. It is extraordinary, considering the ability of the Author, and the many years which he devoted to the composition of his History, and the consequently well-known fact of the existence of such a work, that it should have been carefully preserved from every eye."

    "Nicholas Antonio and Pinelo both name it; but it does not appear that the former saw any of it, or the latter more than a part. That portion of the work, containing an account of the religion, manners, and customs of the new world, was termed apologetical, because he must have endeavoured to palliate in it some manners and customs which were used as a plea, by the greedy proprietors of encomiendas, to press the crown to deprive the Indians of all civil rights, and to reduce them to the condition of absolute slavery. And how could that learned prelate have




                                                  OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.                                               5


    set up a stronger defence for the Indians, than by shewing that their institutions were derived from the Hebrews; however, time, through the perversion of traditions, might have corrupted them?"

    "That the Apologetical History treated of the religion of the Indians is evident, since Torquemeda says that Las Casas asserted in his Apology, in M.S. that "Quetzalcoatl went from Tula to Yucatan," &c. A Spanish writer, giving a sketch of the life of Las Casas, says, speaking of his history, "Las Casas himself, in the year 1556, added a note to it, with his own hand, saying that he bequeathed his History [1] in confidence, to the College of the order of Friars, Preachers of St. Gregory, in Valladolid, requesting the prelates not to allow any layman, nor the collegiates to read it during the period of forty years; at the expiration of which it might be printed, if it was for the advantage of the Indians."

    BERNARD DE SAHAGUN.

    "Bernard de Sahagun, [2] one of the first preachers in New Spain, says that he found it to be a universally received

    __________
    > 1 "This work consisted of six decades, each of which comprised the history of ten years, except the first, which, beginning with the events of 1492, ended in 1500. The learned prelate declared that he had employed thirty-two years in the composition of this work, which comprised the History of the W. I. Islands and Continent, the American Chronicle of Peru and Yucatan, as well as of Nicaragua, Chiapa, Guatamala, Mexico, and the other kingdoms of New Spain; we need not feel surprised that it should have extended to six folio volumes; but that no portion of a work so interesting should ever have been published, either by the Order to which he bequeathed it, or by public authority, or by private individuals, cannot be ascribed to accidental causes. Torquemeda remarks, "Las Casas had many powerful enemies because he spoke great truths." -- p. 265.

    2 Bernard de Sahagun, a laborious Franciscan Spaniard, having been sixty years among the Indians, made great proficiency in the knowledge of their language and history. Besides other works, he composed, in twelve large vols. a Universal Dictionary of the Mexican Language, containing what related to the geography, religion, political and natural history of the Mexicans. This work




    6                                                PRELIMINARY  NOTICES.                                               


    tradition amongst the nations, confirmed by the testimony of their historical paintings, that a colony had arrived long before the Christian era, on the coast of America, from a region situated to the north-east, called Chicomoztoc, first touching on the shores of Florida. The Archbishop of Mexico, Cardinal Lorenzana, afterwards Archbishop of Toledo, who published an edition of Cortez' Letters in Mexico, in the year 1770, would have derived some instruction from the perusal of the History of Sahagun, and certainly would not have assumed it as an undeniable fact, that America had never been colonized from the north-west; neither would he have put a different construction on that passage of the speech of Montezuma to Cortez, where he declares that his ancestors were from the east, than the words of that Monarch fairly admit. The Archbishop says, in a note subjoined to Montezuma's speech. "Los Mexicanos por tradicione viniron por el Norte de la Provecha de Quevera y se Luben ciertamente sus mansiones." This information he perhaps obtained from the examination of some of the confiscated papers of Boturini, which remained in Mexico, in the vice-regal archives, some of which he says were submitted to his inspection."

    "Sahagun, in the prologue to the Universal History of New Spain, expressly says that he was impeded in the progress of his work, by the great discouragement he met with from those who ought to have forwarded it. He states in his second book, that amidst the commendation bestowed upon it, in the Chapter of his Order, which was held in 1569, it appeared to some of the Definitors, that it was contrary to their vow of poverty to expend money on writing such

    __________
    of immense erudition und labour was sent to the royal historiographer of America, resident at Madrid, by the Marquis Villamanrique, viceroy of Mexico. He wrote also the General History of New Spain, in four vols. -- Clavegero Disser.




                                                  OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.                                               7


    histories; and that they therefore obliged the author to discharge his amanuensis, (as he was more than seventy years old, he could not, on account of the trembling of his hand, write at all) and his writings remained for more than five years, without any thing further being done to them. In the mean time, the Provincial deprived the said author of them all, and scattered them over the province. After the lapse of some years, brother Miguel Navarro, came as commissioner to those parts, and recovered, by ecclesiastical censures, the said works at the request of the author. Grateful for the assistance which he had received from the commissioner, Rodrigo de Segura, he dedicated it to him, overwhelming him with eulogies for having redeemed it! -- "rescuing it" as he declares, "from beneath the earth, and even from under the ashes." (265) Sahagun further complains, that he was forcibly deprived of a very valuable painting, representing the great Temple, with the court by which it was surrounded, which he says was sent to Spain. It is very evident that every thing in Mexico, calculated to draw attention to the ancient history of the country, more especially if connected with religious recollections, was carefully removed from notice, immediately after the conquest. Pieces of sculpture were mutilated or buried, -- paintings were burned, -- temples and edifices, which, from their size, it was impossible to destroy, were suffered to fall into oblivion; and magnificent monuments of ancient art, such as the temples of Pelenque, and the palaces of Mitlan, were passed unnoticed by Spanish authors."

    "Sahagun, when engaged in the compilation of his history, after it had been taken away from him and again restored, received three cautions: -- First, to write nothing to prove that the Hebrews had colonized the new world; Secondly, to be guarded in what he said of the Devil's having imitated




    8                                                PRELIMINARY  NOTICES.                                               


    God, in taking to himself a chosen people in the new world, and counterfeiting the rites and ceremonies of the Jews; and, Thirdly, not to advance the hypothesis that Christianity had ever been proclaimed to the Indians, or to treat too largely on the history of Quetzalcoatl."

    "The Bibliotheca of Pinelo, a work, the express object of which was to illustrate the History of America, by extracts from, and references to, valuable and unpublished M.S. preserved in the most famous libraries of Spain and the public archives, especially those of Simancos, to which the author, through the interest of the Duke of Medina de las Torres, obtained access, exists only in an epitome; and of the larger work, a learned writer has observed, "not a leaf has been found." -- Garcia's History of the Peruvian Monarchy is also unknown. -- Siguenza's Mexican Cyclography is stated to have been lost through the negligence of his heirs, and many other interesting works are said to have perished, or been lost in a similar manner. It has been remarked before, that the office of royal historiographer of the Indies does not appear to have been instituted solely for the purpose of promoting the cause of truth, and the increase of knowledge: and it may be further observed that the council of the Indies, which took cognizance of all writers treating of America, requiring that they should be, previously to publication, submitted to a strict censorship, with the power of recalling or prohibiting, even after the publication, any work they thought fit, proceeded in a diametrically opposite spirit." -- Mex. Antiq. vol. vi.




                                                  OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.                                               9


    BOTURINI.


    The Cavalier Boturini, an Italian by birth, visited the New Continent with a view to literary and antiquarian research.

    "This Milanese traveller," observes Humboldt, "had crossed the seas with no other view than to study on the spot the history of the native tribes of America; but in traversing the country to examine its monuments, and make researches into its antiquities, he had the misfortune to fall under the suspicion of the Spanish government. After having been deprived of the fruit of his labours, he was sent in 1736, as a state prisoner to Madrid. The king of Spain declared him innocent, but this did not restore to him his property; and this collection, the catalogue of which Boturini published at the end of his Essay on the American History of New Spain, printed at Madrid, lay buried in the Archives of the University at Mexico; those valuable relics of the culture of the Aztecs were preserved with so little care, that there scarcely exists at present an eighth part of the hieroglyphic records taken from the Italian traveller." -- Mex. Antiq. vol. vi. p. 136-7.

    "Boturini's small work, entitled 'Idea de una nueva Hist. Gen.' &c. published in Madrid, in 1746, notwithstanding his dedication of it to the king, and his preliminary protest which has six different licences for publication prefixed to it, remains unpublished. The preliminary protest is as follows, "Although the occasion of writing this Historical Idea has obliged me to meditate upon the secrets and scientific paintings of the Indians; nevertheless, so far am I from separating myself in the slightest degree from the purity




    10                                                PRELIMINARY  NOTICES.                                               


    of the Catholic religion in which I was born, that I would rather readily die in its defence; and whatever I say here I submit, with the most humble obedience to the judgment, &c. of our holy Roman Catholic and mother church."

    "At this distance of time when the state of the world is so different from what it was in the sixteenth century, it may not be readily conceived how easy it was for the council of the Indies, through the power vested in it, of permitting or prohibiting the general circulation of all writings relative to America, to keep the rest of Europe in a state of darkness respecting the history of the New Continent. For three centuries those who successively composed that council, exercised their function as censors with the greatest vigilance. If powerful patronage or inadvertence on their part suffered in the first instance any obnoxious work to appear in print, it was sure soon to be recalled. Thus the history of the Indies, by Gomara, dedicated to Charles v. and the Conquest of Mexico, by the same author, dedicated to Don Martin Cortez, son of the celebrated conqueror, became prohibited books soon after their publication; but there were other works against which a silent war was waged in Spain. -- ibid. 269 -- 70.

    "We shall only further remark, that the history of Peru is enveloped in much greater obscurity than that of Mexico. The real cause of less being known of the history of the Peruvians in Europe, &c. (notwithstanding Garcillassa de Vega, himself of the race of the Incas, wrote in the latter end of the sixteenth century, a history of Peru,) is probably that Peru was discovered many years after the discovery and conquest of Mexico, and Europe was not to be surprised a second time by a sudden appearance of fresh Ocean Decades and Mythological Paintings." -- p. 270.

    "A part of the paintings collected by Boturini was sent




                                                  OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.                                               11


    to Europe in a Spanish vessel, which was taken by an English privateer. It was never known whether these paintings reached England, or whether they were thrown into the sea as of no value."

    "The greater part of the MS. of Boturini, those which were confiscated in New Spain, were torn, pillaged, and dispersed by persons who were ignorant of the value of these objects. What exists at present in the palace of the Viceroy, composes only three packets, each seven hands square, by five in height. They remained in one of the damp apartments of the ground floor of the Archives of government, which the Viceroy, Count Revillagagedo removed, because of the humidity mouldering the papyrus with alarming rapidity. We feel a sentiment of indignation on seeing the extreme negligence with which these valuable remains were abandoned, which had cost much care and labour, and which the unfortunate Boturini, fired with the enthusiasm which is peculiar to enterprising men, calls in his historal essay, 'the only property which he possessed in the Indies, and which he would not change against all the gold and silver of the New World."

    "The library of the University of Mexico is no longer in possession of any original hieroglyphics. The richest and finest collection of this capital, is that of Jose Antonio Richardo, member of the congregation of San Felipe Neri. The house of this enlightened person, adds Humboldt, was to me what the house of Seguenza was to the traveller Gumilli. Richardo has sacrificed his little fortune in collecting Aztec paintings, and in copying those he was unable to purchase. His friend Gama, author of several astronomical memoirs, bequeathed him all the most valuable hieroglyphics and manuscripts which he possessed. In the new Continent, as well as in the other country, private




    12                                                PRELIMINARY  NOTICES.                                               


    individuals, and those not the most opulent, become the collectors and preservers of objects which are worthy the protection of governments." -- Humboldt, pp. 188-9.

    GARCIA.

    "Garcia, in his famous treatise on the Origin of the Indians, says in the 232nd page, introduction to the third book, Many have supposed, and the Spaniards generally who reside in the Indies believe, that the Indians proceed from theTen Tribes who were lost in the time of Salmanassar, king of Assyria, of whom Rabbi Schimon Sugati, who is named Sincba by Bartolocia, says, nothing is certain, nor is it known where they dwell." This opinion is grounded on the disposition, nature, and customs of the Indians, which they found very similar to those of the Hebrews; and although some learned men are uninclined to assent to such a belief, I nevertheless have bestowed great diligence upon the verification of this Truth. I can affirm that I have laboured in this more than in any other part of my work, and from what I have found thereto relating, I shall lay such foundations for the edifice and structure of this hypothesis, as will be able to contain its weight. The entire of Garcia's third book of the Origin of the Indians, treats accordingly of the likeness which in their laws, their customs, their moral qualities and habits, their ceremonies, sacrifices, and inclinations to idolatry, and even in their early History, the two nations bore to each other. In the first chapter he criticises the passage of the Apocryphal book of Esdras, which induced the Jews themselves to think that they had colonized America, and others to treat with grave attention that singular history. The manner in which they had crossed from




                                                  OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.                                               13


    one continent to another was also a subject of discussion. In the sixth chapter, which is the most curious of all, he institutes a comparison between the Jewish moral and ceremonial laws, and those of the Mexicans, and shows how nearly they agreed. [1] In the seventh he compares the Hebrew language with that of the Indian idioms, and in the eighth he replies to some objections of Acosta." [2]

    GENERAL. NOTICES OF THE OPINIONS OF TORQUEMEDA, HERRERA, D'ACOSTA, GOMARA, CORTEZ, D'OLMES, TORIBIO, BENAVENTE, MARTYR, AND GUMELLA.

    "When we read in Gomara, and other early Spanish historians, of the prodigies which preceded the overthrow of Mexico, so nearly resembling those which Josephus records to have happened shortly before the final destruction of Jerusalem, it is impossible not to perceive the spirit in which these relations were composed, and the feelings which were latent behind the comparison." p. 329. Half revealed truth becomes generally persuasive, as soon as recognized, because those who do not even purpose to bestow information, must certainly be exempt from the charge of deliberately intending to deceive."

    The Peruvians, when first discovered by the Spaniards, had attained a high degree of civilization, and it would

    __________
    1 It must be recollected that the Spaniards intentionally consigned the arts, history, religion, and ancient monuments of America to oblivion, and that they denied to the Mexicans and Peruvians the knowledge of many arts which were arrived at even a flourishing state of perfection among them. "Garcia declares that in Paraguay, iron money resembling in shape the shell of a tortoise, was used, which animal is represented on the oldest Greek coins, those of Thebes." -- p. 68.

    2 A curious parallel of the Hebrews' and Indians' Moral Law may be found in the third book of Garcia's Origin of the Indians, which he has entitled 'Como los Indios guardaron los Preceptos del Decálogo.' How the Indians obeyed the Ten Commands in the Decalogue." -- Antiq. Mex. vol. vi. p. 381.




    14                                                GENERAL  NOTICES.                                               


    appear from a passage of Gomara's History of the Indies, that the Spaniards were struck with the resemblance of some of the tribes of India to the Jews. "They are all very like Jews, in appearance and voice, for they have large noses and speak through the throat."

    "Torquemeda, who does not allow that the Mexicans borrowed any of their analogous customs from the Jews, nevertheless, in treating in the thirty-seventh chapter of the tenth book of his Indian Monarchy, of their art of divination, expresses himself thus, 'Según doctrina falso de estos diàbolicus Rabbinas,' by which he clearly shews the channel of his thoughts."

    "Such was the reserve the Spanish historians imposed upon themselves in treating of Quetzalcoatl (the Mexican Messiah) that his name in fact would scarcely have been handed down to us but for the preservation of a chance copy of the first edition of the Indian Monarchy, by Torquemeda." "Again, it is evident that in Mexico, great pains were taken by the monks and clergy to root out the remembrance of him, and legendary tales relating to his life, were not allowed to be inserted in books published either in that city or in Spain. The temple of Cholula was dedicated to Quetzalcoatl; Bernal Diaz in his history, declares that he had forgot the name of the idol, to whom it was dedicated, although he remembers the number of steps which led up to the temple! This was either out of compliance with the wishes, or in obedience to the command of others." -- p. 169.

    "It is singular that Torquemeda, who was so well acquainted with the Mexican Mythology, should say so little of Totoc, [1] occupying as he does, the next place to Quetzalcoatl,

    __________
    1 c and z sound soft in the Mexican language as s in the English.




                                                  OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.                                               15


    in the Mexican calendar. This silence on the part of Torquemeda, must either be attributed to the oblivion in which half a century had involved many of the religious traditions of the Mexicans, or to the MS. copy of the Indian Monarchy having been mutilated, previously to licence being granted to publish it. Two writers have declared this to be the case. The editor of the second edition complains, that the first chapter of the second book, 'Clave de la de esto obra,' has been entirely omitted; nor did he think it expedient, as he himself says, to request licence to print it, although he adds, "Reasons for secrecy seemed no longer to exist." -- p. 179.

    "The early Spanish writers believed that the Mexican and Peruvian government, laws, and commonwealth, were modelled after the manner of the Jews, though the reason they assign for this is absurd; they say that Satan was jealous of the institutions which God had given to His chosen people, and therefore determined to imitate them in the new world. They have not failed either to point out some curious traits of resemblance to Hebrew usages, in certain acts performed by the Kings and Incas, and in the external marks of reverence these monarchs received from their subjects."

    "Unfortunately, ecclesiastics received no encouragement to write histories of that nation; nor, does it appear that they were allowed to publish them: -- since the works of Mendieta, of Toribio de Benavente, or Motolina, (a copy of whose valuable history Dr. Robertson seems to have procured from Spain; but of which he evidently made no use,) and of D'Olmas and Sahagun, have never been printed; and, strange to say, the royal historiographer of the Indies, Herrera, attempts to discredit the relations of Torquemeda, which may account for the relation of the latter author




    16                                                GENERAL  NOTICES.                                               


    having become so excessively rare, not more than a century after its publication, that the editor of the second edition says, that he despaired for a long time of being able to procure a copy of it in all Spain; but reasons too long to be here recited, perfectly convince us that the office of royal historiographer of the Indies was instituted quite as much for the purpose of veiling as of developing truth. And certainly in a country and in an age where the authority with which a person wrote, was so nicely scrutinized, as the criterion of his merits, Herrera, who really possessed the talents, if he had not the candor of an historian, had it in his power, if he had felt disposed, to deprecate by animadversion, and to consign to oblivion by criticism, the works of contemporary historians, who did not write with the same authority," p. 282, 283. Without stating his reasons for dissenting from Las Casas, he assumes it as an undoubted fact, that the Devil had taken unto himself a chosen people in the new world, and counterfeited in them the history of the children of Israel, and their pilgrimage from Egypt. He assumes this fact, but is very reserved in stating the reasons which induced him to do so, and very concise in his account of the Mexican migration; the same reserve actuating other Spanish historians who possessed equal means of obtaining information with Herrera, has nearly robbed the world of a secret which it is hoped may yet be brought to light." -- Antiq. Mex. vol. vi. p. 263.

    The Mexican paintings seem to have become objects of suspicion and mistrust, even in Europe. The first that were sent to Spain, came to Charles v. in 1519. Peter Martyr mentions them. -- His description corresponds more exactly with the painting which is preserved in the royal library at Dresden; some of the symbols contained in it are not unlike Hebrew letters. Peter Martyr gives the following description




                                                  OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.                                               17


    of these paintings, in an epistle addressed to Leo X. "We have sayde before that these nations have bookes whereon they write, and the messengers, who were procutators for the new colony, Colyahana, brought many of them into Spayne." -- Peter Martyr again says, "I have heretofore sayde that they have bookes, whereof the brought many to Spayne, but this Ribera saith, they are not made for their use of readinge: I suppose them to bee bookes, and that those characters and images signified some other thinges, seeing I have seen the like thinges in the obeliskes and pillars at Rome, which were accounted letters, considering also that we reade that the Caldeis used to write after that manner." "It does not appear that Peter Marytr had the opportunity of seeing any more of 'these bookes.' or that any further presents of that kind were sent to the king of Spain, &c. Ribera, from whom Peter Marytr received the information that the Mexican paintings were merely patterns for clothes and jewels, was the intimate friend and companion of Cortez; he had been four years in Spain and had acquired a knowledge of the Mexican language; he must therefore have known the real use of those paintings, and what his motive could be, in saying that they had no significance nor meaning, it would be difficult to explain." "Rigid orders were given shortly afterwards, to the Bishop and clergy of New Spain to cause them all to be burnt." "Spain passed some extraordinary laws, prohibiting lawyers, surgeons, literati, Jews, heretics and the descendants to the third generation, of persons, suspected by the Inquisition, and foreigners of all sorts, who had not received a license at Seville, from passing over to America."

    "Father Joseph Gumilla says, in page 59 of the Oronoco Illustrada, 'I affirm, in the second place, that the nations of Oronoco and its streams, observed many Hebrew ceremonies,




    18                                                GENERAL  NOTICES.                                               


    during the time of the paganism which they followed blindly and rudely, without knowing wherefore, (ceremonies) that had been transmitted by traditions, handed down from father to son, without their being able to assign any reason for the practice of them.' -- p. 272. Torquemeda, acknowledging that the religious rites, ceremonies, and even moral laws of the Indians closely resembled those of the Jews, thought it more probable that the devil had instructed the Indians in them, than that the Hebrews had carried them over to America. Learned men of the present age will not consider themselves bound by the example of those of the sixteenth century; and that learning is most useful, the object of which is the attainment of truth, with a regard for the best interests of mankind."

    "All that Peter Martyr says of Huitzilopoctli, the tutelary deity of Mexico, whose temple he briefly describes in his eight decades, is comprised in a single line, in the fourth chapter of his fifth decade, where he writes to Adrian VI. 'It is a fearful thing to be spoken, what they declare and report concerning their idols;' and he does not so much as mention Quetzalcoatl." p. 329.

    "On the supposition that Cortez discovered the Jewish religion, established in Mexico, it is easy to assign a reason for the three years' delay, in sending over regular clergy from Spain, notwithstanding the pressing solicitations which Cortez, publicly at least, made to the Emperor, to that effect: since the real cause might have been to avoid scandal, and to have time to root out, by the secular arm, the traces of Judaism, which could not fail to strike a clerical order of men, however they might have been overlooked by the military followers of Cortez. It is proper however to observe that this delay, which seems very extraordinary, considering the age, the zeal of the Spanish nation, and




                                                  OF  SPANISH  HISTORIANS.                                               19


    above all, the state of the new vineyard, is ascribed, in the second chapter of the fifteenth book of Torquemeda's history, to other causes, amongst which are enumerated the death of Pope Leo X, and the Emperor's doubts whether he could conscientiously annex to the crown of Spain, the newly discovered kingdom. The analogy between many of the Mexican and Jewish superstitious afford convincing proof that they were derived from a common source, and it is a curious fact that many obscure passages of Scripture may be elucidated by referring to the works of Torquemeda, Gomara, and Acosta."

    "Herrera, almost in the very words of Acosta, notices, in the seventeenth chapter of the second book of his third Decade, that custom (viz. circumcision) as prevalent amongst the Mexicans; and Bernal Diaz is quite explicit on the subject, in the following passage of the 207th chapter of his history of the continent of New Spain. 'In some provinces they were circumcised, and they had flint knives with which they performed the ceremony.' p. 334. Since no testimony can be more positive as to a matter of fact than that of Bernal Diaz, respecting the existence of this rite amongst the Indians, his means of information can alone be called in question; but that point he has himself settled by premising to his account of these sacrifices, this remark -- 'The sacrifices which I have seen and known, I write down here from memory.' Of the history of Bernal Diaz, but one opinion has been formed, that its style is rude, and the narrative perfectly authentic. Dr. Robertson thus characterizes it -- 'It contains a prolix, minute, and confused narration of all Cortez' operations, in such a rude vulgar style as might be expected from an illiterate soldier. But as he relates transactions of which he was a witness, and in which he performed a considerable part, his account bears all the




    20                                                GENERAL  NOTICES.                                               


    marks of authenticity, and is accompanied with such a pleasing naïveté, with such interesting details, and with such amusing variety, and yet so pardonable in an old soldier, who had been, as he boasts, in 119 battles, as renders his book one of the most singular that is to be found in any language.' 'The earliest Spanish writers, who wrote on the affairs of America, such as Peter Martyr, (who scarcely would have ventured to have stated a deliberate falsehood to the Pope, and one which he, sooner than any other person, would have been capable of detecting,) and Gomara, who was chaplain to Cortez, and dedicated his History of the Conquest of Mexico to Don Martin Cortez, his son, and therefore had the best means of information; and Bernal Diaz, and other Spanish writer