Orson Hyde (1806-aft 1893) 1832 Missionary Journal (excerpts) Title-page Introduction Rigdon at Mentor Mormons at Kirtland Kirtland Temple Transcriber's comments |
PIONEER AND PERSONAL REMINISCENCES. MARSHALLTOWN, IA: MARSHALL PRINTING COMPANY. 1893. |
cccccccccccccc |
Document 1: 1832 Samuel H. Smith comments (excerpts) Source: Smith, Samuel H., "Journal," LDS Church Historian's Archives, UT. Typescript in Dale R. Broadhurst Papers, Marriott Library, University of Utah. (Also partly transcribed in Cheryl H. Bean's Rediscovering History. . . St. Anthony, ID, 1995). Note 1: According to Samuel H. Smith, he and Orson Hyde first approached (New) Salem, Ashtabula Co., Ohio from the west, having trekked towards that town after leaving neighboring Kingsville. The "Christian congregation" they came across was probably located between the hamlet of Amboy and the western limits of Salem, on the old lakeshore road. The following day, Feb. 14, 1832, the missionaries appear to have walked into Salem. Orson Hyde said they "sold two Book of Mormons" in that area on the previous day. Thus, it is possible that the missionaries were in West Salem on the 13th. Note 2: The movements of the missionaries on the 14th and 15th are somewhat obscure. They must have left Salem town limits and spent some time on the shore of Lake Erie. While this stopping point may have been on the PA side of the state line, it is more likely that the two waited until the afternoon of Feb. 15th or the morning of the 16th to cross Conneaut Creek and walk into Springfield Twp., Erie Co. PA. According to Smith, the two then "went into the village again," where they "held a meeting in the school house," probably on Feb. 14th. The only "village" of any size in the immediate vicinity was Salem. Here is where Aaron Wright in 1833 said that Orson Hyde "preached" in "the school house" and was heard by Nehmiah King, a local Salem resident who had known Solomon Spalding. Hyde in 1841 said himself: "In the spring of 1832 I preached in New Salem, Ohio the place where Rev. Mr. Spaulding resided at the time he wrote his romance." It is likely that the two "school houses" were one in the same and that Feb. 14 (or, possibly 15), 1832 was the day that Orson Hyde preached in the Salem Center School. Note 3: Daniel Tyler in 1878 said "In 1832 Elders Orson Hyde and Samuel H. Smith preached a few times in our neighborhood and baptized three persons, among them Erastus Rudd . . ." As Tyler and his family were then living immediately across the state line (in Springfield Twp,. Erie Co., PA) at this time, it appears that Erastus Rudd's baptism may have been shortly after Hyde and Smith began preaching in Springfield -- probably c. Feb. 21-27, 1832. It should be noted that there was no Mormon branch established in New Salem (Conneaut) during the 1830s. The closest LDS congregation was located in Springfield twp., Erie Co., PA and the members probably generally met just north of West Springfield hamlet, in the vicinity of the Rudd farm. |
Document 2: 1832-33 Hyrum Smith comments (excerpts) Source: Smith, Hyrum, "1832-33 Diary," Lee Library, BYU. Partial typescript in Special Collections, Marriott Library, University of Utah. Note 1: This Hyrum Smith Diary includes entries from November 20, 1832 to June 7, 1833. This particular source (then in private hands) does not appear to have been consulted by Pearson H. Corbett in his 1963 biography Hyrum Smith, Patriarch. In his book Corbett speaks of "Hyrum Smith's Diary" and says (in a note on page 96) that the diary was then in the "possession of his descendants." Corbett quotes from that diary through the month of November 1832 (on page 105) and provides a single brief entry for December. He then says: "Here Hyrum discontinued his entries. He kept no journal until the following spring." On page 110 of his biography Corbett resumes quoting from Hyrum Smith in an entry made on April 18, 1833, saying that "the journal, after a lapse of time, is continued," and also noting that "the dates on entries in the diary are not chronological..." It is possible that the "1832-33 Diary" is an overlapping record kept separately by Hyrum Smith. Or, it may be comprised of pages which somehow became detached from the source quoted from by Corbett. Note 2: Hyrum Smith does not identify his 1833 missionary companion in Erie Co., PA. However, Orson Hyde provides this information: "In the spring of 1833, I, in company with Hyrum Smith, went on a mission to Elk Creek township, Erie County, Pennsylvania, where we labored several weeks... Assuming Hyde left Kirtland in Hyrum Smith's company, he would have been the second party in the "we" Smith speaks of when saying he and his traveling companion "arrived at Springfield" on March 28th, after having been "Rejected & Cast out by them," (i.e. their auditors in some unspecified place between Painesville and Springfield). The logical stopping places within the 30 miles separating these two points would have been all been in lakeshore Ashtabula Co. Perhaps the hostile encounter came in the town of Ashtabula or even Solomon Spalding's old residence of New Salem. Note 3: The names abbreviated by Hyrum Smith in his entry for April 5, 1833 are: J Murdock = John Murdock, Z Coulton = Zebedee Coltrin (Coulton is a variation of the name frequently encountered in Erie Co., PA), L Johnson = Lyman E. Johnson, O Prat = Orson Pratt, Doct Hulburt = Doctor Philastus Hurlbut, D. Copley = Daniel Copley, O. Hide = Orson Hyde. Journal entries made by Zebedee Coltrin speak of this same mini-conference of April 5, 1833, but do not tell that it was for "the purpose of seperating Doct[or Philastus] Hulburt [and] D[aniel] Copley," or that the meeting was held at "Brother [Stephen] Winchesters." Note 4: Missionaries Daniel Copley and D.P. Hurlbut were no doubt separated so that Hurlbut's character and actions would nolonger habe a direct impact on "young" Copley. In this way Hurlbut was under seasoned missionary Orson Hyde's direct supervision and control. There were at least two possible reasons for this action: 1) to restrain Hurlbut from investigating the Spalding authorship claims then in circulation in that region of the country (Jackson's Crossroads, PA Conneaut, OH, etc.); and 2) in order to thwart Hurlbut's presumed physical affair with young Mormon convert Huldah Barnes (1806-1898). Benjamin Winchester, the son of "Brother [Stephen] Winchester," recalled that "He [Hurlbut] joined the Mormons and became an elder. He seduced a girl named Barns. We as the church, to cover up the matter, urged him to marry her. He refused and then we expelled him..." Huldah was probably baptized in April of 1833 in Conneaut twp. Erie Co., PA, perhaps by D. P. Hurlbut himself. Her older sister, Anna Barnes Harmon (1798-1847) was baptized there on May 29th by Hurlbut's missionary companion, Orson Hyde. Huldah was likely the "Mormon woman of very bad character, who lived alone" recalled by Rachael Miller Derby as playing hostess to D. P. Hurlbut in Erie Co. during Sept. 1833. Although she became a plural wife of Heber C. Kimball in 1846, Huldah apparently had a penchant for living alone -- both in WI among the Strangites and later in UT, where she died a single woman in 1898. |
Document 3a: 1832 Jared Carter comments (excerpts) Source: Carter, Jared, "Journal," LDS Church Historian's Archives, UT. (Partly transcribed in Cheryl H. Bean's Rediscovering History... St. Anthony, ID, 1995). Note 1: Jared Carter makes the interesting statement that three of the Springfield Mormons bapatized by Samuel H. Smith and Orson Hyde in Feb. 1832 were already "falling away" from the Church by the time Carter and his missionary companion Ebenezer Page visited there in late April 1832. This dampening of their convert zeal may have been, in part, due to news emanating from neighboring Salem, Ohio that the Book of Mormon had been written by local author Solomon Spalding. Erastus Rudd and his brother, John Rudd, Jr. appear to have been among the faithful members who held true to the LDS cause. Note 2: On the other hand, Daniel Tyler in 1878 said there was no local "talk of the Spaulding romance being connected with the Book of Mormon until about 1834 or 1835, when Henry Lake began to claim" such things in nearby Salem. Daniel may have been off by a few months in this recollection, for his own convert father, Andrews Tyler, had deserted the Mormons prior to his excommunication at the hands of Orson Pratt on Dec. 5, 1833. Thus, the "great opposition and falling away" noticed in the Springfield Branch by Jared Carter may well have occurred concurrently with the first outward spread of the Spalding authorship claims from "next door" in Ashtabula Co., OH. Note 3: The "Chole Rudd" and "Fanny Mariah Rudd" who were baptized at the end of April, 1832 by Carter and Page were family members of Erastus and John, Jr -- Chloe Hills Rudd was their mother and Fanny Mariah was the daughter of Chloe's son, Erastus Rudd and his wife Experience Wheeler Rudd. This couple named their next child (born June 22, 1832) "Sidney Rigdon Rudd." |
Document 3b: 1833-34 Orson Pratt comments (excerpts)
Source: Pratt, Orson, "Journal," in Watson, Elden J. (ed) The Orson Pratt Journals Salt Lake City: self-published, 1975, pp. 16-27) Note 1: Orson Pratt and his missionary companion Lyman E. Johnson left Kirtand on March 26, 1833, the same day as Hyrum Smith left on his own preaching and administrative mission to Erie Co., PA. It is possible that the three traveled together through OH. According to both Hyrum Smith and Zebedee Coltrin, Orson Pratt was present at Springfield in Erie Co., PA on April 4th and 5th. Coltrin again encountered the two (perhaps at Silver Creek, Chautauqua Co., NY) on April 22nd, on his way to Warsaw (then in Genesee Co.). While passing through Chautauqua Co. Coltrin contracted smallpox. Pratt says nothing about this minor epidemic then raging in that county. Note 2: Evan M. Green speaks of meeting "O. Hyde" on Apr. 28, 1833 at the LDS Elk Creek branch. In the same passage he goes on to list "Bro. Hyde," apparently for a second time. Perhaps the first Mormon mentioned here was actually "Orson Pratt." Note 3: Pratt mentions working to overcome local problems among the members of the Springfield and Elk Creek branches between Dec. 1 and 5, 1833. He officiated in the excommunication of Andrews Tyler on the 5th. Two other Erie Co. members were cut off at this same time. According to an 1883 account provided by his son Daniel, Andrews Tyler "admitted that the 'Mormon' doctrines were true, but claimed that the members of that church had adopted them to cover up a fraud." (Daniel Tyler, "Incidents of Experience," in: Classic Experiences and Adventures Salt Lake City: Bookcraft, 1969), p. 24. The "fraud" Andrews Tyler spoke of was probably in regard to actual origin of the Book of Mormon, as the Solomon Spalding authorship claims for that book were then beginning to circulate among the residents of neighboring New Salem, OH. |
[1833: June 7] Elder Lyman E. Johnson and myself, having received a commandment, through the Prophet, to visit the churches and preach in the Eastern States, left Kirtland on the 26th of March to fill our mission. We arrived in Bath, New Hampshire, on the 7th June... [1833: Sept. 28] We arrived in Kirtland, having been absent six months, during which time I had traveled about 2,000 miles... [1833: Nov. 27] November 27th. Brother Lyman and I, having been set apart by a council of High Priests to visit the Churches, accordingly took our leave of Kirtland and went to Springfield. [1833: Dec. 1] December 1st. Preached in Springfield upon the Gospel. [1833: Dec. 2] December 2nd. Went to Elk Creek and attended a Church meeting. Brother Zebedee being present. Two were cut off from the Church. [1833: Dec. 3] December 3rd. Went to Springfield. [1833: Dec. 4] December 4th. We attended a Church meeting in Springfield and settled some difficulties among the brethren. [1833: Dec. 5] Attended another Church meeting in the same place and cut off from the Church Brother Tiler. [1833: Dec. 6] December 6th. Preached at Elk Creek. [1833: Dec. 8] December 8th. Being the Sabbath preached at the same place upon the two places of gathering. [1833: Dec. 11] December 11th. Held a conference in the evening and regulated some difficulties between Henry Dighton and Harrison Sagers, and also between Zebedee Coltrin and Moses Martin. Brothers Harrison and Moses were found to be under condemnation, but after confessing, were permitted to retain their offices. Brother Lyman E. Johnson also ordained Brother Amasa Lyman to the office of High Priest. [1833: Dec. 12] December 12th. Brother Lyman, Amasa and I left Elk Creek and came to Westfield... |
Document 4: 1832 Orson Hyde comments (excerpts)
Source: Hyde, Orson, "Journal," LDS Church Historian's Archives, UT. Typescript of original holograph journal on at the Utah Historical Society, Salt Lake City, Utah. (Partial reprints avilable in Cheryl H. Bean's Rediscovering History. . . St. Anthony, ID, 1995 and Howard H. Barron's Orson Hyde 1977, UT) view more of this document at the Mormon Classic E-Texts web-page Note 1: Orson Hyde's journal entry for Feb. 10, 1832 says that he and Samuel H. Smith stopped in Kingsville, Ashtabula Co., Ohio at "Mr. Woodbury's." This was likely the residence of Wheeler Woodbury or, perhaps, of one of his sons. Wheeler's daughter Maria married D.P. Hurlbut in Kingsville in 1834. As Hyde says he and Smith "Left Mr. W's house, went on to Salem" on Feb. 11, they no doubt took advantage of the Woodburys' hospitality and spent the night there. Reference to Samuel H. Smith's journal entries shows that he and Hyde remained on the western outskirts of (New) Salem until about Feb. 13th or 14th. Note 2: Hyde's mention of having sold "two Book of Mormons" in the New Salem area on Feb. 13th is consistent with claims by several of the so-called "Conneaut witnesses" for the Spalding authorship claims -- that they had read the book locally c. 1832-33. Hyde's entry for Feb. 19th may contain his attempt to write "Mr. Rudd." There was both a "Reed" and two or three "Rudds" who entertained Mormon missionaries in this vicinity at the same time. Samuel H. Smith calls apparently the same man "Erastus Rudd." Note 3: Hyde and Smith baptized at least six men in the Springfield area between Feb. 20 and Feb. 27, 1832. These were the core of the Springfield Branch of the Mormon Church, which was apparently organized at some unrecorded date between late February and the middle of March, 1832. When Evan M. Greene visited the young congregation ten months later, there was a functional LDS branch in Springfield. Though the Mormons did well at first in Erie Co., PA, they accomplished much less immediately across the state line in Salem and the surrounding townships of Ashtabula Co., Ohio. It is possible that Nehmiah King's Feb. 1832 allegation regarding a Solomon Spalding authorship for the Book of Mormon served to subdue the Saints' missionary success in that part of the country. King was a lawyer and had served in Ashtabula Co. as a Justice of the Peace. His neighbor and fellow Spalding-associate was Henry Lake, whose son Zaphna became the Sheriff of Ashtabula Co. a year after the 1832 visit of missionaries Hyde and Smith. |
Document 5: 1864 Orson Hyde Autobiography (excerpts) Source: Latter Day Saints' Millennial Star XXVI:47-50 (Nov.-Dec., 1864). view the full document at the Mormon Classic E-Texts web-page Note 1: The historical series of articles comprising the "History of Brigham Young" was presented throughout 1864-1865 in the pages of the Liverpool based Millennial Star. Supplementing the main biography of LDS President Young were numerous biographical sketches of other leaders in the Utah Church. The "History of Orson Hyde" appears to be an autobiographical story composed primarily by Hyde himself. What source materials (such as his own journal entries, copies of correspondence, etc.) Hyde may have consulted in preparing this article remain unknown; however, his retelling of events previously recorded in his 1832 mission journal makes that document one probable source. Note 2: The information in Hyde's autobiographical sketch is taken primarily from his years before converting to the Latter Day Saints and from his early missions carried out for their church. To some extent Hyde appears to have transferred his earlier dependence upon and loyalty to Sidney Rigdon over to Hyrum Smith in about 1832-33. Hyrum would ever after be Orson's benefactor, a role which he may have played as early as June 1833 when Hyde was elevated to the position of personal clerk to Joseph Smith, Jr. and the other members of the Mormon First Presidency. Hyde's presumed shift in personal allegiance at that point in his life may help explain why he is so candid in admitting that he'd heard of Smith's "golden bible" being "dug out of a rock in the state of New York. According to Hyde's own words he "not long after" this " became a convert to this new faith" of the Campbellites, of which "Elder S. Rigdon was its chief advocate." While Hyde may have felt secure in stating this remarkable admission in 1864, it is almost unthinkable that he would have made the close connection between the "golden bible" and Rigdon's version of Campbellism as early as 1827, had he remained under Sidney Rigdon's protective influence. Note 3: Note: Richard VanWagoner says in his Sidney Rigdon, page 55: "Publication of the "Golden Bible," as people were calling it, had been recounted in several Western Reserve and New York newspapers as early as 1827, when Joseph Smith began working on the book. There can be little doubt that Rigdon, an enthusiastic reader of newspapers, was aware of the book before it was placed in his hands." He then recounts Orson Hyde's remembrance that "a 'golden bible' had been dug out of a rock in the State of New York.'" This recollection by Hyde should be compared also to Eliza Snow's complementary statements. |
Document 6: 1955 Marvin S. Hill comments (excerpts) Source: "An Historical Study of the Life of Orson Hyde . . ." Unpublished Master's thesis, Brigham Young University, Provo, UT, 1955. Note 1: Although this thesis has never been copyrighted, only limited excerpts are provided here, due to the fact that the text may be copyrighted at a later date. |
Document 7: 1977 Howard H. Barron comments (excerpts) Source: Barron, Howard H. Orson Hyde. . . 1977, UT. Note 1: The entire contents of this book copyright © 1977 by Horizon Publishers. Only limited, "fair use" excerpts are reproduced here. |
Howard H. Barron Horizon Publishers COPYRIGHT © 1977 BY HORIZON PUBLISHERS All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or any parts thereof in any form or by any media without written permission is prohibited. INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BOOK NUMBER 0-88290-076-5 LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARD NUMBER 77-74490 Printed in the United States of America by Horizon Publishers & Distributors P.O. Box 490 50 South 500 West Bountiful, Utah 84010 |
(Courtesy of LaMar C. Barrett) In the winter if 1826 and the spring of 1827, after working at four different jobs, Orson returned to the Gilbert and Whitney store in Kirtland for "moderate wages."15 When business declined in the spring, he stopped clerking and began "making pot and pearl ashes" The Spirit of Religious Revivalism Swept Over the Kirtland Area Kirtland and vicinity were also filled with the spirit of religious revivalism. In 1827, at age 22, Orson attended a Methodist camp meeting about six miles from Kirtland and was converted; he was later appointed a Methodist class leader. During his period of activity in the Methodist faith, Orson became aware of newspaper reports "that a 'Golden Bible' had been dug out of a rock in the State of New York."17 These reports, treating the subject lightly, concerned Orson little; he reffered to the whole account as aŹ"hoax," but later wrote that one of his passing reactions was, "Who knows but that this 'Golden Bible' may break up all our religion, and change its its whole features and bearing?"18 |
Transcriber's Comments
|