OliverCowdery.com -- The Premier Web-Site for Early Mormon History


THE WILLIAM MORGAN HOME PAGE








Illust. of Masonry (1826) |  Narrative of Anti-Masonick Excitement (1827) |  Norman Bentley Items & Anti-Masonic Texts (1820s)
Masonic Martyr: Eli Bruce Biography (1861) |  The Broken Seal (1870) |  History of the Abduction & Murder of Wm. Morgan (1873)
History of Abduction of Wm. Morgan (1874) |  Christian Cynosure (1875-99) |  Wm. Morgan & Political Anti-Masonry (1883)
Thomas A. Knight Book & Articles (1932-34) |  William L. Cummings Articles (1934) |  Morgan, Mormons & Masonry (1946)


The Broken Seal
(Boston, Mass., 1870)







Title Page  |  Contents  |  Morgan Kidnapped  |  Kidnapping Aftermath  |  Appendix





THE


B R O K E N  S E A L;

OR,

PERSONAL  REMINISCENCES

OF  THE


MORGAN  ABDUCTION  AND  MURDER.

BY

SAMUEL  D.  GREEN.



_______





BOSTON:
PUBLISHED BY THE AUTHOR,
AND FOR SALE AT NO. 13 BEACON ST.
1870.







[ 2 ]







Entered, according to Act of Congress, in the year 1870, by
SAMUEL D. GREENE,
In the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the District of Massachusetts.









STEREOTYPED AT THE
BOSTON STEREOTYPE FOUNDRY,
19 Spring Lane.







[ 3-4 ]



C O N T E N T S.

___________
CHAPTER I.
INTRODUCTION.    .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .    .    .    .    .    .    .  5

CHAPTER II.

HOW I BECAME A MASON.    .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .    15

CHAPTER III.

CAPTAIN WILLIAM MORGAN AND COLONEL DAVID C. MILLER.  .    .    .    .   31

CHAPTER IV.

THE STORM GATHERING.    .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .    .   47

CHAPTER VI.

ABDUCTION OF MORGAN.    .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .   .  71

CHAPTER VI.

ATTEMPTED ABDUCTION OF MILLER AND HIS RESCUE.   .    .    .    .    .    .    .   99

CHAPTER VII.

WHAT BECAME OF MORGAN.    .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .    .    .    .    .    .    .   .    .    .  117

CHAPTER VIII.

WHAT MORGAN ACTUALLY REVEALED.    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    146

CHAPTER IX.

MY SUBSEQUENT EXPERIENCES WITH MASONRY.    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .     159

___________


APPENDIX.

THE WAY IN WHICH A MAN WAS ENTICED INTO MASONRY.    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .  183

HOW OLD IS MASONRY?    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    .    . 188

MR. MILLER'S TESTIMONY BEFORE A GENESEE COURT. . . . 197

ANTIMASONIC POETRY. ....... 205

MASONRY INCONSISTENT WITH A REPUBLICAN GOVERNMENT. . . . 211

PERSECUTIONS OF S. D. GREENE, IN A SERIES OF LETTERS TO SOUTHWICK'S NATIONAL OBSERVER. . . . 215

"ABORTIVE ATTEMPT'' TO PUNISH THE MORGAN ABDUCTORS. . . . 232

EXTRACTS FROM THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE NEW HAMPSHIRE ANTIMASONIC STATE CONVENTION. . . . 287

CONFESSION OF THE MURDERER OF WILLIAM MORGAN. . . . 296

ALLEGATIONS AGAINST FREEMASONRY. . . . 300





[ 5 ]




THE  BROKEN  SEAL.
_______

CHAPTER I.

I N T R O D U C T O R Y.


Sensible that I am drawing near the close of life, I feel it my duty to leave on record certain facts connected with my personal history, which may be of use to those who shall come after me. My life has been a long and eventful one; but I have no intention of writing an autobiography, except in relation to one feature of my history. Many years ago, I was brought, in the providence of God, into strange and intimate association with a series of events which deeply affected my own mind, and, for a long time, powerfully agitated society. I refer to the abduction and murder of Captain William Morgan, for unfolding what he deemed to be the pernicious secrets of the masonic order. I was a member of the same lodge with




6                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


him, was intimately acquainted with the man, and was an eye-witness of much that went on concerning him. I am prepared, therefore, to bear testimony on this subject, such as few other living men probably can give. To the rising generation the story is, in some good degree, a new one; but forty years ago, the whole land was moved with excitement in consequence of it.

Believing, as I most sincerely do, that the institution of Freemasonry, in its natural working, is injurious alike to individual and public morality, that it is secretly hostile to good and wholesome government, and still more hostile to the Christian church, I feel it my duty, before leaving the world, to tell what I have personally known of these things, and bear my testimony in this regard.

In doing this I trust I am not moved by a sense of private wrongs, or by any personal animosities. Almost all of those who were in active life with me at the time the events above referred to took place, are now sleeping in the grave. This is no time for personal griefs and resentments. I have passed beyond that period when the honors and emoluments of this world can greatly affect me. The generation with which I have acted my part on the stage is gone, or fast disappearing. It is




                                                    INTRODUCTORY.                                                    7


because I believe that what I have to relate has an intrinsic interest and a valuable lesson for others, that I am moved to tell it.

After this long lapse of years, I am aware that in little things my memory at times may be at fault. But all the substantial points of this narrative were matters of record at the time, and they were, moreover, events of such deep interest, taking such strong hold of the thoughts and feelings, as not to be easily effaced from the recollection. In small and unimportant details there may be an occasional mistake; but in the great things of the narrative -- the larger outlines -- I am not likely to be mistaken. At my period of life the memory is far more alive and fresh with reference to matters forty years ago, than to events of more recent occurrence. The only value which such a personal history as this can have, is its honest and reliable truth. My aim will be to make this narrative strictly truthful, whatever other elements it may lack. It shall be a straightforward story of what I myself passed through.

In respect to such items of the narrative as did not actually fall under my own personal inspection, but were yet connected with the same general




8                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


series of events, I have constantly referred to contemporary history, and have consulted especially Rev. David Bernard's "Light on Masonry." At the time of the Morgan abduction and murder, Mr. Bernard was a member of the masonic lodge at Covington, in Wyoming County, only about twenty miles distant from Batavia. He had been for some years a Mason -- had been led into it under the general representation that it was "an institution from Heaven; moral, benevolent, of great antiquity, the twin sister of Christianity, possessing the patronage of the wise, the great and good, and highly important to the ministers of Jesus Christ." Under this general impression he was taken, as I was, through the first three degrees, only to awaken in him the same disgust which I myself experienced after passing over the same road. "My disappointment," he tells us, "none can know but those who have, in similar circumstances, been led in the same path of folly and sin. I silently retired from the institution, and for three years was hardly known as a Mason." Still, by the representations of others, he was made to believe that there was some great good in the higher masonic degrees, and he started again and travelled on his way until he entered




                                                    INTRODUCTORY.                                                    9


the Lodge of Perfection, and took the ineffable degrees.

After all the experience he had, his opinion of the institution is summed up in the following plain, and unmistakable language: he "found it wholly corrupt; its morality, a shadow; its benevolence, selfishness; its religion, infidelity; and that, as a system, it was an engine of Satan, calculated to enslave the children of men, and pour contempt upon the Most High.''

At the time of the Morgan abduction, Mr. Bernard was absent from home. He returned on the 16th of September, only five days after the ab-duction, to learn that Morgan was taken off and probably murdered. He says, "I conversed with Masons on the subject, and they justified both his abduction and murder." From that moment he broke with the institution; came out boldly and denounced it; was, in fact, the first Mason that openly took this stand. For so doing he was threatened on every hand, and subjected to a long course of dangerous and most annoying persecution. But he held his ground, and three years after, in 1829, he published his volume of six hundred pages, in which are carefully gathered up all the chief records of those exciting times. This




10                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


book has been at hand while preparing this little volume, that I might refresh my memory upon any point about which I was in doubt.

I am not unmindful of the fact that Freemasonry is again popular and wide-spread in the land. In the opposition which arose after the Morgan murder, the institution throughout the country was greatly weakened and depressed. For twenty years little was heard of Masonry. Many of the lodges, in all directions, returned their charters and wound up their affairs. But in the coming on of the anti-slavery agitation, public attention was gradually called away from Masonry and its evils, and the institution, being left alone in the dark, with its few bigoted devotees, began to revive, until again it assumes a bold front, and stalks abroad with large pretensions. It is for this reason especially that I am induced to tell the story of the past. Most men, in connecting themselves with Masonry, take little thought of the consequences. By the peculiar and strange fascination which it has for many people, they are drawn within its embraces, and they do not reason carefully enough upon the subject to comprehend what effects are wrought by it upon themselves personally, or upon society at large. I do not




                                                    INTRODUCTORY.                                                    11


charge upon members of the masonic order generally, that they have any direct and conscious intentions against their neighbors, or the peace and welfare of community. They do not set out with the idea of being enemies either of God or man. But they belong to an institution which has its own laws and its own methods of working, and by it they are shaped and controlled in ways that they know not of. Working under cover of secrecy and darkness, it fortifies itself little by little, and in a thousand ways attempts to secure for its own members advantages over others in the privileges and honors of life.

In a recent public debate on Freemasonry, an officer in our late army, who was taken prisoner, and who spent weeks and months in Southern prisons, boldly undertook to defend the institution by showing the good which came to him personally from officers in the Southern army, when he was known and recognized as a Mason. This is a very easy and short argument if one will only consent to stop at the proper point. But in strict truth and honor, what right had others to give, or he to secure for himself in this way, kind offices, harshly denied to his fellow-prisoners? A soul truly manly would spurn benefits which must




12                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


come in through such by and forbidden channels, and would choose to suffer what others were called to suffer. How far is this secret giving and secret snatching after good from that broad Christian rule, "Whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them " !

But the important point, in all such arguments as this, is, that it opens up a vista far beyond what the speaker intends. If Southern officers would show these partialities, and be false to their trusts, under such circumstances, so would Northern officers; and you have a traitorous element in both camps, taking and giving without regard to general orders, or the general good. A man who will confess that he would accept such advantages in the dark, does thereby confess that he would give such advantages in the dark -- that a Freemason's grip would have power and influence beyond the general claims of the nation and of humanity. Take this principle and carry it out into all the details of life, and it is a most enormous crime against society. And undoubtedly, if we could get at the facts, we should find that many things, in the progress of the late Avar, which seemed strange and inexplicable at the time, and which still seem so, would be easily explained by this




                                                    INTRODUCTORY.                                                    13


principle of individual favoritism working boldly against the general good. *

In war or in peace this can never be any other than a most mischievous and dangerous element in society. In the course of my life, and from my special means of knowledge and observation, I have seen the working out of this principle in so many ways, that I cannot but regard it as one of the most gigantic crimes against government and our common humanity. Masonry sometimes parades before the world its good and charitable deeds; its kindness shown between man and man; its care for the widow and orphan; and on the score of benevolence, dares to make comparison between itself and the church of Christ, forgetting that even its benevolence, so called, is founded upon selfishness. It is not, it does not even claim to be, that broad Christian benevolence which looks upon every man as a brother, and which makes the Samaritan neighbor to the Jew,

__________
* In the third degree the Mason swears to help his brethren and seek their deliverance under all conditions of calamity, murder and treason only excepted." In the higher degrees this provision drops out, and he promises the like assistance, "murder and treason not excepted." Wherever, then, in all the world, the Mason gives the "grand hailing sign of distress," by his two uplifted hands, all true Masons are expected to govern themselves accordingly, and rush to his relief.




14                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


in spite of long ages of prejudice and hate. Ma-sonry is something very different indeed from all this. It gives only in expectation of receiving as much again. And although this is the common way of the world, the rule most largely followed in individual action, yet men ordinarily do not try to incorporate it into institutions, and make it look noble by large combinations. It retains its old nature in spite of organization It is intrinsically selfish, and not benevolent, and the more odious just in proportion as the attempt is made to lift it into prominence.

I will not, however, attempt, in this abstract way, to set forth the evils and wrongs of Masonry. I have an actual story to tell, -- a deeply interesting story, -- which will show the real workings of the institution in a far more graphic way than I could otherwise exhibit them; and to this personal narrative we will at once turn.






                                              HOW  I  BECAME  A  MASON.                                              15




CHAPTER II.

HOW  I  BECAME  A  MASON.


I was born in the town of Leicester, Mass., on the 7th day of February, 1788. My great grandfather, Thomas Greene, was the first Baptist minister in that town, and through his agency the first Baptist meeting-house was built there. In my childhood, the country was just emerging from the fatigue and burdens of the long war of the Revolution. It was the day of small things. Society was in a rude and simple condition, as compared with the present. The means and opportunities of education were very inferior to those now enjoyed in New England. My education, during the early years of my life, in consequence of this fact, as also because of the frequent interruptions of sickness, went on irregularly. But at the age of fourteen I was set upon the study of Latin, at Leicester Academy, and was so far advanced in general education, that at the age of seventeen I




16                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


was employed to teach a district school in the neighboring town of Oakham, I was examined by the parish minister, Rev. Daniel Tomlinson. I was certainly not very well fitted for my new vocation by reason of the irregularities of my education; but some references which I made to Latin, and Latin rules of grammar, rather impressed the minister with my youthful learning, and I found no difficulty in obtaining my certificate.

This Mr. Tomlinson was a quaint and original man, and some pleasant stories are told of him. He was a native of Connecticut, a graduate of Yale College, and was settled in Oakham in 1786, where he remained for fifty years. If I mistake not, he is the man about whom the famous church story of Oakham centres. In the time of a long and obstinate quarrel, when the members in church meeting assembled were accusing each other variously, the minister finally rose and said, --

"Brethren, this must be stopped. If the Lord will have a church in Oakham, he must have it out of such materials as we have here." He is the same man also to whom a church member once went complaining, and wanting a letter of dismission to the church in a neighboring town. Said




                                        HOW  I  BECAME  A  MASON.                                        17


the church member, '' There are so many Achans in the camp here, that I want to get away to another church." ''O," said the minister, "I guess I wouldn't go. We can take care of the Achans here as well as they can anywhere."

The following winter I taught school in Thompson, Ct., and was examined and approved by Rev. Daniel Dow, the minister of the Congregational church at Thompson from 1796 to 1849. He also was remarkable for his quaintness and keen wit, and was a man of much repute in the ecclesiastical affairs of his state.

In the intervals of my teaching I was attending school at Leicester Academy, and in 1807, at the age of nineteen, I entered the Sophomore class in Brown University. Here I remained for more than two years, when I was employed as assistant teacher in the principal school of Providence, and took my dismission from college at the close of the first term of my senior year. And here, on the 29th of March, 1810, I was married to my first wife, Miss Susan Gibbs.

I need not stop to detail the varied experiences of my life for the first few years after my marriage. In 1812 began the war with Great Britain. The country was in a very depressed and uneasy




18                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


condition. New England, especially, suffered during all that season. Dependent so largely as she then was upon her commercial enterprises, those three years of war were with her years of sore discouragement and calamity.

In the year 1816 I prepared to remove, with my family, to Western New York. I had just before made a journey thither myself, and had concluded to cast in my fortunes with the new and chaotic society then forming in that portion of the country. The only place of much importance in Western New York had been Buffalo. That was burned in the war of 1812, and was now slowly rising again. The region far around was in a wild or half-broken state. Accordingly, in 1816, I bought a horse, additional to the one I before owned, had a pole put into my wagon instead of the pair of thills, before used, covered the wagon with a piece of sheeting, put in such things as were most necessary, took my wife and two little children, and started for the west. It was a long and toilsome journey, of about five hundred miles, over a rough country. Twenty hours would now suffice to make the journey along our great railroad tracks; but at that time it was a laborious enterprise, requiring weeks for its execution.




                                        HOW  I  BECAME  A  MASON.                                        19


Our first residence was at Pembroke, about twenty-eight miles this side of Buffalo, where, for a time, I kept a public house, and engaged in various occupations, such as are natural in a new, rough, and sparsely-settled country. Previous to the war of 1812, and subsequently until the Erie Canal was built, the merchandise and produce of the country were transported to and fro between Albany and Buffalo, a distance of between three hundred and four hundred miles, in large covered wagons, with wheels of broad tire, drawn by teams of from four to eight horses. A number of these teams would be owned by one m;in, who usually accompanied them as a general superintendent of the journey. He would travel with a single horse in a light buggy, to give direction and assistance, in times of difficulty, to go forward and arrange stopping-places for the night, to see that hay and grain were in readiness for the horses, and provisions for the men on their arrival. In such a country the tavern was a great institution. My house, called the Brick Tavern, at Pembroke, was a convenient and natural stopping-place for these teams; and not unfrequently it would happen that from fifty to a hundred horses must be provided for at my barns for the night, and the teamsters taken




20                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


care of in the house. The life these men lived was a rough, hard, and adventurous one, and brought out the strong and sharp qualities of character, rather than the refined and graceful. This was before the days of the temperance reformation, and no small part of the business of the tavern-keeper was to provide suitable liquors for travellers, and for the dwellers around.

Many unique stories might be told of what transpired at my house during those years, illustrating the character of my guests, and also illustrating the state of society around me. One night there arrived at my house some eighty horses, with a due proportion of teamsters. In company with them came a foot traveller, with his knapsack, in which he carried the necessaries of life, victuals and drink. He had overtaken the teams a little way back, and inquired of the men where they were intending to stop for the night. "At the Brick Tavern, Mr. Greene's," was the reply. "Well," says the footman, "I will stop there too." These teamsters were good and generous customers. Their habits of life lifted them above all small and stingy ways. They had supper, lodging, and breakfast, liquor and cigars, for themselves, and feed for their horses, all bought and




                                        HOW  I  BECAME  A  MASON.                                        21


paid for at the hotel. They did not attempt to carry any of these things along with them, though they might easily have done so.

On the other hand, all that this foot-traveller wanted was a good nice fire to sit by, and a bed to sleep in. He carried his food and liquor in his knapsack, and ate his supper from this in my bar-room. I had at that time an energetic man who served in the double capacity of barber and boot-black. In the course of the night this man gave a splendid shine to all the boots, the footman's included, as he had left them out for the purpose.

In the morning he rose and ate his breakfast in the bar-room, from his own knapsack, just as he had done his supper. At length the hour for starting arrived, and the teamsters gathered at the bar to settle their bills. As the custom then was, I set out my decanters of different liquors, that they might take a parting drink at their pleasure. After they had finished, up came the foot-traveller and inquired for his bill. "What have you had?" said I. "O, lodging," said he (the boot-black standing by and giving a most significant glance at his shining boots). "Your bill is six cents, then," said I, that being the customary charge at that time for a bed, in that part of the




22                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


country. He paid the sixpence, and then, looking at me, said, "Landlord, can't you afford to treat?" "To be sure," said I; "what will you have?" "I'll take a little brandy." I turned out a half-pint tumbler nearly full (the teamsters all looking on). He took it and drank nearly half of it. Then stopping, said he, " In fact, I can't drink it all." "Haven't you a little flask you can put it into?" said I. He took out his flask, and I emptied the remainder of the brandy into it. "Well," said he, turning to the teamsters, I don't wonder you stop here. It is the best tavern I ever saw. I shall always stop here, landlord, when I travel this way." "Do," said I, "by all means." After they left my house the teamsters _run him_ hard upon his meanness. They told the story all the way from Buffalo to Albany, and so advertised my house thoroughly, and gave me a fine run of custom.

In 1822 we removed from Pembroke to Batavia, eleven miles farther east, and near the centre of Genesee County. This was the county seat. Soon after going there I opened the County House, as it was called, opposite the Court House. In about a year I admitted into the house a private female school. The Presbyterian minister of the place was Rev. Calvin Colton, since well known by his




                                        HOW  I  BECAME  A  MASON.                                        23


writings. His wife, a woman of very superior education and character, had charge of the school that was kept in my house. My wife and I connected ourselves with Rev. Mr. Colton's church, and our children were baptized by him. In 1823 and 1824 Mr. Colton's parish was engaged in erecting a meeting-house; and when it is stated that this was the first real meeting-house built in Genesee County, it will help reveal the new and rude condition of society in Western New York at that time. This house was a good one, and was furnished with a steeple and a bell. Batavia at that time had, perhaps, two thousand inhabitants, and was a place of great importance, as the land office was there.

In Batavia was a Freemason's lodge, known as Lodge No. 433. Some of the principal citizens of Batavia were connected with it. The oldest deacon of our church was a strong and enthusiastic Mason, and was wont to say that he should as soon think of speaking against the God of heaven as against the institution of Masonry. Dr. Dibble, the physician in my family, was one of our church session. He was also an earnest Mason.

After accommodating the above-named school in my liouse for a time, I found that it interfered




24                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


with my proper business of hotel-keeping; and so the school was removed. My house was known now as the Park Tavern, or County Hotel. The building stood opposite the new park.

About this time an effort was made, in Batavia, to increase the interest in Masonry, and to gather new members into the lodge. Significant hints and invitations were given me from time to time, and I was at length prevailed upon to allow myself to be a candidate for admission into the order. Mr. Ebenezer Mix, the then surrogate of Genesee County, resident at Batavia, proposed me as a member, and I was admitted to Lodge No. 433 in the month of December, 1825, taking the first, or entered apprentice's degree, and in a week more I took the second and third degrees the same night.

Everything is so contrived in Masonry, that there shall be no going back when one is fairly launched upon the stream. There are many degrees in Masonry; but the mischief is concentrated in the entered apprentice's oath. At the very outset, and before this oath is taken, the candidate is so drawn in and entangled with promises of one kind and another, that he sees no possibility of turning back. He is put through a course




                                        HOW  I  BECAME  A  MASON.                                        25


of preliminary nonsense, offensive to his moral sense, and degrading to his manhood; but he sees no chance of breaking away without raising about him a scene which he has not at the time the courage to encounter.

Before the oath is taken, the candidate is divested of all his apparel, -- shirt excepted, -- and furnished with a pair of drawers, kept in the lodge for the use of candidates; the candidate is then blindfolded, his left foot bare, his right in a slipper, his left breast and arm naked, * and a rope called a cable-tow round his neck and left arm, in which condition he is conducted to the door, where he gives, or his conductor gives for him, three distinct knocks, which are answered by three knocks from within, and a voice calls out three times, "Who comes there?" The poor fool on the outside

__________
* The masonic language, describing the general condition of the candidate about this time is as follows: --

Q. "How was you prepared?"

A. "By being divested of all metals, neither naked nor clothed, barefoot nor shod, hoodwinked, with a cable-tow about my neck, in which situation I was conducted to the door of the lodge."

The reason given in general for putting the candidate in this condition, is that Masonry is something of extreme antiquity -- that it originated in a rough and primitive age, when the manners of men were rude, and they wish to preserve strictly the "old landmarks."




26                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


is then made to say, or his condnctor says for him, in answer to this momentous question, "A poor blind candidate, who has long been desirous of receiving and having a part of the rights and benefits of this worshipful lodge, dedicated to God, and held forth to the holy order of St. John, as all true fellows and brothers have done, who have gone this way before him." After a deal more of idle ceremony, including prayers and forms semi-religious, the candidate is at last brought in a kneeling posture, with his left hand under the Bible, square and compass, and his right hand upon them, and in this attitude, blindfold and half naked, and with the assurance that what he is doing shall not affect his politics or religion, he takes the entered apprentice's oath, as follows: --

"I, A B, of my own free will and accord, in presence of Almighty God, and this worshipful lodge of Free and Accepted Masons, dedicated to God, and held forth to the holy order of St. John, do hereby and hereon most solemnly and sincerely promise and swear, that I will always hail, ever conceal, and never reveal, any part or parts, art or arts, point or points, of the secrets, arts, and mysteries of ancient Freemasonry, which I have received,




                                        HOW  I  BECAME  A  MASON.                                        27


am about to receive, or may hereafter be instructed in, to any person or persons in the known world, except it be a true and lawful brother Mason, or within the body of a just and lawfully constituted lodge of such, and not unto him or unto them whom I shall hear so to be, but unto him and unto them whom I shall find so to be after strict trial and due examination, or lawful information. Furthermore, do I promise and swear, that I will not write, print, stamp, stain, hew, cut, carve, indent, or engrave it on anything, movable or immovable, under the whole canopy of heaven, whereby, or whereon, the least figure, character, mark, stain, shadow, or resemblance of the same may become legible and intelligible to myself or any other person in the known world, whereby the secrets of Masonry may be unlawfully obtained through my unworthiness. To all which I do most solemnly and sincerely promise and swear, without the least equivocation, mental reservation, or self-evasion of mind in me whatever; binding myself under no less penalty than to have my throat cut across, my tongue torn out by the roots, and my body buried in the rough sands of the sea at low-water mark, where the tide ebbs and flows twice in twenty-four hours. So




28                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


help me God, and keep me steadfast in the due performance of the same."

In December, 1825, I took this oath, going through all the attendant nonsense. Until the oath was imposed upon me, I had no adequate conception of its nature. Many a man, on going through these first ceremonies, has been utterly shocked and horrified at what he has done, and at the frightful obligations he has taken upon himself. His first disposition is to draw back, and have no more to do with an institution which uses such awful sanctions to cover and conceal what is of no real consequence to mankind. * His whole moral nature is shocked at such profane and enormous trifling. Many who take this oath, as soon as may be, withdraw from all active participation in the affairs of the lodge, finding that they have been deceived, and have embarked upon a course which their moral sense cannot approve. But it is difficult to do this at once, and abruptly. Many men, however, who have no keen moral sense, who are, in fact, only boys of a larger growth, seem to find great delight in the foolery of this institution. The big words and sentences, which

__________
* Appendix A.




                                        HOW  I  BECAME  A  MASON.                                        29


have to be mouthed over so often, exactly suit their taste. The endless forms and ceremonies, to be gone through with night after night, continue, to their undiscerning eyes, to wear the semblance of a majestic greatness. As children find a certain delight in playing with edged tools, so they handle these awful sanctions, these oaths and penalties, with a strange fascination. There is about the whole institution a certain barbaric glitter and pomp exactly fitted to please swelling and half-developed men; and these will stay fast by the lodge, and make it the great glory of their lives to manage its affairs, and mouth over its illustrious names and titles.

Of the thousands and tens of thousands, who, by one influence and another, are enticed within its folds, not many are at once launched upon such a wild scene of excitement and terror as it was my lot to encounter. Little did I dream, when I took upon myself the entered apprentice's oath, what was so speedily to follow; that then and there, in Lodge 433, was to take place that which would fill the whole land with intense excitement, moral and political, and would bring the institution itself of Masonry almost to the verge of destruction. By the act of that night in December, 1825,




30                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


I had brought myself into the midst of a conflict of thoughts and feelings hard to be described, and where, at times, it was exceeding-ly difficult to know what to do, or whither to turn.










                            CAPTAIN  MORGAN  AND  COLONEL  MILLER.                             31




CHAPTER III.

CAPTAIN WILLIAM MORGAN AND COLONEL
DAVID C. MILLER.


31




32                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


32




                            CAPTAIN  MORGAN  AND  COLONEL  MILLER.                             33


33




34                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


35




                            CAPTAIN  MORGAN  AND  COLONEL  MILLER.                             35


35




36                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


36




                            CAPTAIN  MORGAN  AND  COLONEL  MILLER.                             37


37




38                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


38




                            CAPTAIN  MORGAN  AND  COLONEL  MILLER.                             39


39




40                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


40




                            CAPTAIN  MORGAN  AND  COLONEL  MILLER.                             41


41




42                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


42




                            CAPTAIN  MORGAN  AND  COLONEL  MILLER.                             43


43




44                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


44




                            CAPTAIN  MORGAN  AND  COLONEL  MILLER.                             45


45




46                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


46






                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              47




CHAPTER IV.

THE  STORM  GATHERING.


47




48                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


48




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              49


49




50                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


50




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              51


51




52                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


52




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              53


53




54                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


54




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              55


55




56                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


56




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              57


57




58                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


58




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              59


59




60                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


60




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              61


61




62                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


62




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              63


63




64                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


64




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              65


65




66                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


66




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              67


67




68                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


68




                                              THE  STORM  GATHERING.                                              69


69




70                                                    THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                   


70






                                              ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                              71




CHAPTER V.

ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.


The events of Sunday night, September 10, had demonstrated that Batavia was full of the elements of mischief; that the conspirators had not dispersed, but were on hand, watching their opportunities. In the early morning of Monday, September 11, while everybody was busy talking over the exciting events of the night before, the rumor ran abroad that Captain Morgan had been seized and taken off. He went out of his boarding-house, a little before sunrise, into the street, and not returning, as usual, to breakfast, inquiry was made for him, when it appeared that he had been taken about seven o'clock, had been roughly forced into a stage, and carried off in the direction of Canandaigua. A man by the name of Nicholas G. Chesebro, of Canandaigua, who was Master of the masonic lodge in that place, had obtained from the justice of the peace there a




72                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


72




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                73


73




74                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


74




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                75


75




76                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


76




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                77


77




78                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


78




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                79


79




80                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


80




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                81


81




82                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


82




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                83


83




84                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


84




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                85


85




86                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


86




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                87


87




88                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


88




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                89


89




90                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


90




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                91


91




92                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


92




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                93


93




94                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


94




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                95


95




96                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


96




                                                ABDUCTION  OF  MORGAN.                                                97


97




98                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


98






                                ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER.                                99




CHAPTER VI.

ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER
AND  HIS  RESCUE.


99




100                                                   THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                  


100




                              ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER.                               101


101




102                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


102




                              ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER.                               103


103




104                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


104




                              ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER.                               105


105




106                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


106




                              ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER.                               107


107




108                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


108




                              ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER.                               109


109




110                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


110




                              ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER.                               111


111




112                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


112




                              ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER.                               113


113




114                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


114




                              ATTEMPTED  ABDUCTION  OF  MILLER.                               115


115




116                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


116






                                        WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                        117




CHAPTER VII.

WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.


117




118                                                   THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                  


118




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      119


119




120                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


120




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      121


121




122                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


122




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      123


123




124                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


124




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      125


125




126                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


126




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      127


127




128                                                   THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                  


128




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      129


129




130                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


130




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      131


131




132                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


132




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      133


133




134                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


134




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      135


135




136                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


136




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      137


137




138                                                   THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                  


138




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      139


139




140                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


140




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      141


141




142                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


142




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      143


143




144                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


144




                                      WHAT  BECAME  OF  MORGAN.                                      145


145






146                                                   THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                  




CHAPTER VIII.

WHAT  MORGAN  ACTUALLY  REVEALED.


146




                            WHAT  MORGAN  ACTUALLY  REVEALED.                            147


147




148                                                   THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                  


148




                            WHAT  MORGAN  ACTUALLY  REVEALED.                            149


149




150                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


150




                            WHAT  MORGAN  ACTUALLY  REVEALED.                            151


151




152                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


152




                            WHAT  MORGAN  ACTUALLY  REVEALED.                            153


153




154                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


154




                            WHAT  MORGAN  ACTUALLY  REVEALED.                            155


155




156                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


156




                            WHAT  MORGAN  ACTUALLY  REVEALED.                            157


157




158                                                   THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                  


158






                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     159




CHAPTER IX.

MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES  WITH  MASONRY.


159




160                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


160




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     161


161




162                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


162




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     163


163




164                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


164




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     165


165




166                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


166




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     167


167




168                                                   THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                  


168




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     169


169




170                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


170




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     171


171




172                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


172




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     173


173




174                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


174




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     175


175




176                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


176




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     177


177




178                                                   THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                  


178




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     179


179




180                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


180




                                      MY  SUBSEQUENT  EXPERIENCES.                                     181


181




182                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


182






[ 183 ]




A P P E N D I X.
_______

A.


183




184                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


184




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          185


185




186                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


186




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          187


187






188                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 




A P P E N D I X.
_______

B.

HOW  OLD  IS  MASONRY?


188




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          189


189




190                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


190




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          191


191




192                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


192




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          193


193




194                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


194




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          195


195




196                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


196






                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          197




C.


197




198                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


198




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          199


199




200                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


200




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          201


201




202                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


202




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          203


203




204                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


204






                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          205




D.

ANTIMASONIC  POETRY.


205




206                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


206




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          207


207




208                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


208




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          209


209




210                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


210






                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          211




E.


211




212                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


212




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          213


213




214                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


214






                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          215




F.


215




216                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


216




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          217


217




218                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


218




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          219


219




220                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


220




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          221


221




222                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


222




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          223


223




224                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


224




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          225


225




226                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


226




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          227


227




228                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


228




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          229


229




230                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


230




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          231


231






232                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 




G.


232




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          233


233




234                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


234




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          235


235




236                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


236




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          237


237




238                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


238




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          239


239




240                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


240




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          241


241




242                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


242




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          243


243




244                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


244




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          245


245




246                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


246




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          247


247




248                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


248




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          249


249




250                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


250




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          251


251




252                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


252




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          253


253




254                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


254




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          255


255




256                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


256




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          257


257




258                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


258




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          259


259




260                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


260




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          261


261




262                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


262




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          263


263




264                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


264




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          265


265




266                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


266




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          267


267




268                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


268




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          269


269




270                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


270




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          271


271




272                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


272




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          273


273




274                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


274




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          275


275




276                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


276




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          277


277




278                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


278




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          279


279




280                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


280




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          281


281




282                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


282




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          283


283




284                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


284




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          285


285




286                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


286




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          287


287




288                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


288




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          289


289




290                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


290




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          291


291




292                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


292




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          293


293




294                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


294




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          295


295






296                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 




I.


296




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          297


297




298                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


298




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          299


299






300                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 




SUPPLEMENTARY  NOTE.


300




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          301


301




302                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


302




                                                         APPENDIX.                                                          303


303




304                                                  THE  BROKEN  SEAL.                                                 


304



Return to top of Page



William Morgan Home Page     |     Oliver Cowdery Home Page
Bookshelf  |  Spalding Library  |  Mormon Classics  |  Newspapers  |  History Vault

last updated: Feb. 4, 2015